Pepsi Rookie of the Year Nominees Announced

[Jackofalltrades]

How many are playing this week? crickets crickets crickets

How many were instrumental in their teams playing this week?

I don't think he deserves to win it, I agree he should get the nod over Watkins.

[UKPanther94]

Meh, can't complain too much, Benjamin has had a real good season but ultimately lack of consistency probably swung it, but I doubt it would make much difference as Beckham has that award sewn up so it would have taken something ridiculously special to usurp that

[Ricky Spanish]

ODJ deserves it. Watching him play receiver is just damn FUN.

 

Single handedly won me my fantasy league this year too. If you don't think he deserves it then you are high. It was like watching a 5 year vet out there. 

[Mother Grabber]

Watkins is in there due to name recognition.

[tailg8or]

KB has had flashes, but doesnt deserve it over anybody on that list. He needs to work hard this offseason on improving his hands.

[Jeremy Igo]

Agreed that KB shouldn't be on the list. Too many important drops and routes left unfinished.

[Cpt slay a ho]

Carr had a good season despite the record

[rayzor]

oh well.

 

it's not like anyone stood a chance with odell anyway.

[Catweisers]

Drops got him and he probably knows it.  Benji done a fine job this year for us but it could have been finer!!!

The great part of this equation Benji is still playing and his rookie status is not quite set yet !!!  Game Ball, Chicken of the Sea game, his Rookie season gets lot brighter. 

He is fun to watch and has caught a lot of fine passes this year and some were "did he really do that"kind. 

Good Luck at game Benji get that game ball!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Chaos]

The obvious choice is OBJ. He's had one of the best rookie wr seasons in history, so I'd be surprised if he doesn't win this award.

Personally the dark horse for this could be Mike Evans. For him to put up over a thousand yards and 12 TDs with the QBs he had to work with this season is pretty damn good. It makes me wonder what his stat lines could have been if he had a better QB throwing his way.

 

I would agree that Mike Evans should get it just based on those numbers in the Tampa Bay offense.  OBJ missed a good bit of games didn't he?  But I guess his ESPY play of the year three-fingered catch sealed the deal for him.  He's definitely a stud WR.

[PantherFanOne]

II agree that Kelvin Benjamin should not have made the list. I hope his problem dropping passes and route running can be corrected this offseason, with additional coaching and hard work.

[Mol3m4n]

Carr is better than Bridgewater.

[crowntownpanther]

Bet KB is pissed he's not on that list. Not because he was screwed, but because he knows he could've been if he had been more consistent hanging on to catches. Would love to see this get him riled up and step up big time against the LOB this weekend.

[CarolinaSamurai]

Agreed that KB shouldn't be on the list. Too many important drops and routes left unfinished.

I disagree because Sammy doesn't deserve to be up there at all. Even with KBs drops he had more yards/TDs than Sammy. Either neither should be there or KB should.