NFL.com Year End QB Rankings

[firstdayfan]

5 or so years ago Panthers had the number 1 pick and luck was the number 1 prospect. Panther fans spent the whole season screaming "suck for luck". luck decided to stay in school to finish his degree and the rest is history. dumb, retarded forum drama history.

 

Oh I remember...still makes no sense whatsoever.

[mc52beast]

You're judged on wins and losses, not whether you're playing behind a sorry o-line or your OC stinks. Just a fact of NFL life.

[teeray]

Oh boy, another one of THESE threads.

Oh boy, another one of THESE posts.

[teeray]

Andrew Luck

16-2 Vs Jaguars, Titans, Texans

17-13 Vs Everybody Else

10-10 last 2 years

[teeray]

Lol yea Luck is bad because he is in the AFC south yet our division had losing records and 7-8 got us in the playoffs....yea Cam has had zero weapons despite jstew getting close to 1k yards and having two 1k receivers and a solid defense, not to mentions his ability to run himself, his biggest strength every cam-highlight-media-yuppie-fanboy claims he should base his play on....or maybes it's Cam's relationship with his OC who had a 12-4 record last year and was Cam's QB coach helping him be one of the greatest rookie QBs of all time.

Guys give me a fuging break. Cam had some awful games this year and up until recently has been wildly inconsistent and was better the previous years, and that isn't even debatable.

It's true he has not had an online and that's all I'm willing to give Cam. Now I do think Luck is overhyped but I also think fanboys on here overhype Cam. Luck is the better QB as of now, get the fug over it.

All valid points.

But as bad as the NFCS is, the Bucs would be the 2nd best team in AFCS

[TheRumGone]

I think cam and luck should be compared throughout their entire careers. That's how much I think of both qbs

[tiger7_88]

Witty thread.

 

Yet here you are.

 

Weird, right?

[tiger7_88]

Lol yea Luck is bad because he is in the AFC south yet our division had losing records and 7-8 got us in the playoffs....

 

 

Cam has been in the league for 4 years... for 3 of those years, the NFC South was one of the toughest divisions for a team to be in.

 

Luck has been in the league for 3 years.  How many of those years has the AFC South been a challenging division?  I'll only give you one shot to get the correct answer.

[tiger7_88]

That decision really broke their hearts I guess.

 

At least their posts give all the self-righteous a-holes the chance to point out how much better and smarter they are than those who post about it, amirite?

[csx]

All valid points.

But as bad as the NFCS is, the Bucs would be the 2nd best team in AFCS

No way

[teeray]

The 9-7 Texans say hello.

They aren't very good. Tampa and them would be neck and neck.

They got 4 wins against Tennessee and Jacksonville.

They got a win against the Raiders

They got a win against the Redskins and Giants

They got a win against Cleveland.

One win against the Ravens that was worth a flip.

Tampa Bay wins at least 7 games against that schedule. Hell Tampa even beat the Steelers so maybe they get 8 or 9 wins against that schedule.

It would be close. They are about the same team

[teeray]

This is imperfect but let's look at their schedules.

Tampa gets 4 wins against Tennessee and Jacksonville.

Tampa beat the snot out of Washington so that is a win

They both played Steelers and Tampa won

That is 6 wins.

Tampa played Cleveland really close so maybe they could have squeaked that one. There is 7 wins

Tampa > Raiders

So there is 8 wins

Then maybe they get one against the Giants or Bills

9-7

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

All valid points.

But as bad as the NFCS is, the Bucs would be the 2nd best team in AFCS

And panthers would be 3rd

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

This is imperfect but let's look at their schedules.

Tampa gets 4 wins against Tennessee and Jacksonville.

Tampa beat the snot out of Washington so that is a win

They both played Steelers and Tampa won

That is 6 wins.

Tampa played Cleveland really close so maybe they could have squeaked that one. There is 7 wins

Tampa > Raiders

So there is 8 wins

Then maybe they get one against the Giants or Bills

9-7

Really dumb. Tampa got a whopping 2 wins in one of the worst divisions ever...

And if you want to do transitive property , then Houston beat Baltimore, who DOMINATED the nfcs