NFL.com Year End QB Rankings

[Jackofalltrades]

This is maddening. I'm one who thinks Luck is vastly overrated so to see him ranked with the Elites while Cam is mid-pack despite early musings of MVP consideration is painful. Give Luck, or 90% of QB's, the OC, OL and receivers Cam was burdened with and see where they wind up.

Cam had his struggles, but he started the season behind the 8 - ball and still managed to win when it mattered most.

He has a chance Saturday to shut up some critics.

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000452624/article/qb-index-yearend-rankings?campaign=Facebook_atn_rosenthal

[firefox1234]

Players and especially QBs are measured by wins, until he does that he wont get respect from these "experts". I love Cam more than the next fan but that is just a fact of life.....

[The Huddler]

It sucks, but ive gotten used to the Cam Newton disrespect.

Im so thankful that he is my QB

[Dex]

Why is DA not in the top 5?

[Kuhndog94]

Why is DA not in the top 5?

He's the only QB that's undefeated and he hasn't thrown any INTs.

He should be #1.

[Dex]

He's the only QB that's undefeated and he hasn't thrown any INTs.

He should be #1.

He's also a really classy guy and takes this poo serious.

[Brooklyn Bully]

Oh boy, another one of THESE threads.

[Dexterity]

Andrew Luck is an average QB. He is a product of the AFC South, just like Peyton Manning was before him. There's a reason they both put up gaudy regular season numbers then crumble in the playoffs. Luck gets to play HOU, TEN, & JAX twice each season. Almost half of his games are against teams that have been bottom 5 franchises in the NFL for over a decade.

Vs AFCS: 16-2 W/L, 35 TD, 15 Tov

Vs Rest: 17-13 W/L, 63 TD, 41 Tov

[Ruff]

This is maddening. I'm one who thinks Luck is vastly overrated so to see him ranked with the Elites while Cam is mid-pack despite early musings of MVP consideration is painful. Give Luck, or 90% of QB's, the OC, OL and receivers Cam was burdened with and see where they wind up.

Cam had his struggles, but he started the season behind the 8 - ball and still managed to win when it mattered most.

He has a chance Saturday to shut up some critics.

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000452624/article/qb-index-yearend-rankings?campaign=Facebook_atn_rosenthal

ok

[Jackofalltrades]

ok

Witty retort.

[London Loves Luke]

Get used to it, we've got the Colts next year. Luck vs Cam threads took a backseat to Hardy and SS89 threads this season.

Next season Luck vs Cam homerism is gonna be back with a diarrhoea inducing vengeance.

[†William Moore†]

Luck and Wilson are products of the ESPN hype machine.

 

Luck had a good season (40TDs) but still don't believe he's more than average. 

 

Wilson is the ultimate game manager. Without a defense and running game he is worthless. 

 

an argument can be made for Luck in the top 10, but certainly not Wilson. 

[Ruff]

Witty retort.

Witty thread.

[blackcat]

The media has been in love with Luck since college. It's called propaganda, Luck gets the good kind, Cam, not so much.

Cam was demonized by the media for laptops and getting paid to play. They're not going to do an about face and give him some respect until he wins a ring, maybe.

Get used to it.