Carson Palmer vs. Jay Cutler

[Johnny Rockets]

Which one will have the better fantasy season?

[Guild]

I'd wait until the end of preseason to call this one.

On a hunch I'll pick Palmer though (Ocho Cinco and no RB of note to suck up points).

[X-Clown]

I'd say Cutler, the injuries of Palmer's elbow and now ankle scare me.

[Johnny Rockets]

In my draft I took Cutler in the 8th round and now I am having a bit of buyer's remorse since Palmer was still on the board. Only 4pts per passing TD though. In the grand scheme of things, Cutler vs. Palmer should not make or break my season so I probably shouldn't worry about it.

I guess since they will be my number 1 (Orton is my backup) I should probably stay with the safer (from an injury standpoint) Cutler.

[RedMage138]

Palmer, Cutler has no receivers in Chicago. Palmer has 3 top flight guys in Cincy and Cedric Benson is his running back...

[Sultan33g]

Had Cutler last year was more of a disappointment then I thought