Halfway through preseason, what's your depth chart looking like?

[Cyberjag]

I know a lot can change between now and September, but I'm curious what you all think where the depth chart is concerned.

Mine looks a little like this.

QB - Jake Delhomme, Matt Moore, Josh McCown

RB - DeAngelo Williams, Jonathan Stewart, Mike Goodson

FB - Brad Hoover, Tony Fiametta

WR - Steve Smith, Kenny Moore, Jason Carter

WR - Muhsin Muhammad, Dwayne Jarrett

LT - Jordan Gross, Travelle Wharton

LG - Travelle Wharton, Mackenzie Bernadeau

C - Ryan Kalil, Mackenzie Bernadeau

RG - Keydrick Vincent, Duke Robinson

RT - Jeff Otah, Geoff Schwartz

TE - Gary Barnidge, Jeff King, Dante Rosario

RDE - Julius Peppers, Everett Brown, Hilee Taylor

UT - Damione Lewis, Corey Irvin

NT - Nick Hayden, Marlon Favorite

LDE - Tyler Brayton, Charles Johnson

WLB - Thomas Davis, James Anderson

MLB - Jon Beason, Dan Connor, J Leman

SLB - Na'il Diggs, Dan Connor, Landon Johnson

CB - Richard Marshall, Captain Munnerlyn

CB - Chris Gamble, Sherrod Martin

FS - Charles Godfrey, Quentin Teal

SS - Chris Harris, Dante Wesley

Defense, 25

Punter - Jason Baker

PK - John Kasay

Kickoffs - Rhys Lloyd

Long Snapper - J. J. Jansenn

[ItsNotGonnaBeAlright]

Ryne Robinson has looked a lot better than Jason Carter so far, so I would give him the edge at reciever. Also, I think Wesley get's dropped in favor of DT signing. Other than that, I would agree with this roster.

[Cyberjag]

If we sign a DT I suspect Hayden will find that his seat on the PS is still warm.

[bigdog10]

Dropping Wesley would be dumb....He brings his lunch pail on Special teams, and has been better in coverage than either of the two rookies

[beastson]

my back field would be this

CB - Richard Marshall, Captain Munnerlyn

CB - Chris Gamble, Charles Godfrey

FS - Quentin Teal, Sherrod Martin

SS - Chris Harris, Dante Wesley

Then I think with a year under his belt at CB, Godfrey would definitely be our number 2 corner next year

[KillerKat]

So far, this is who looks like they deserve to be on there:

OFFENSE:

WR1: Steve Smith - Dwayne Jarrett - Ryne Robinson

LT: Jordan Gross

LG: Travelle Wharton - Justin Geisinger

C: Ryan Kalil - Mackenzy Bernadeau

RG: Keydrick Vincent - Duke Robinson (DP)

RT: Jeff Otah

TE: Gary Barnidge - Jeff King - Dante Rosario

WR2: Muhsin Muhammad - Kenneth Moore

QB: Jake Delhomme - Matt Moore - Josh McCown

FB: Brad Hoover - Tony Fiammetta (DP)

RB: DeAngelo Williams - Jonathan Stewart - Mike Goodson (DP)

DEFENSE:

LE: Tyler Brayton - Charles Johnson

DLT: Nick Hayden - Marlon Favorite

DRT: Damione Lewis - Corvey Irvin (DP)

RE: Julius Peppers - Everette Brown (DP) - Hilee Taylor

SLB: Na'il Diggs - Jeremy Leman - Landon Johnson

MLB: Jon Beason - Dan Connor

WLB: Thomas Davis - James Anderson

LCB: Chris Gamble - C.J. Wilson - Sherrod Martin (DP)

RCB: Richard Marshall - Dante Wesley - Captain Munnerlyn (DP)

SS: Chris Harris - Quinton Teal

FS: Charles Godfrey

SPECIAL TEAMS:

K: John Kasay - Rhys Lloyd

P: Jason Baker - Rhys Lloyd

KO: Rhys Lloyd - John Kasay

H: Jason Baker

DS: J.J. Jansen - Gary Barnidge - Ryan Kalil

KR: Mike Goodson (DP) - Ryne Robinson - Captain Munnerlyn (DP) - Kenneth Moore

PR: Captain Munnerlyn (DP) - Ryne Robinson - Kenneth Moore - Mike Goodson (DP)

Geisinger apparently played LT in college and Macky played RG/RT. I think if Otah went down, Macky could play RT. I think if Gross went down, Wharton would go to LT and Duke at LG. However, if Wharton gets hurt and then Gross, I think Otah would slide in at LT with Duke at LG and Macky at RT. Geisinger would probably be a last resort at LT. Schwartz and Cadogan just haven't shown that they deserve a roster spot.

[panthersphan]

QB - Jake Delhomme, Matt Moore, Hunter Cantwell

RB - DeAngelo Williams, Jonathan Stewart, Mike Goodson

FB - Brad Hoover, Tony Fiametta

WR - Steve Smith, Kenny Moore, Ryne Robinson

WR - Muhsin Muhammad, Dwayne Jarrett

LT - Jordan Gross, Travelle Wharton

LG - Travelle Wharton, Mackenzie Bernadeau

C - Ryan Kalil, Mackenzie Bernadeau

RG - Keydrick Vincent, Duke Robinson

RT - Jeff Otah, Geoff Schwartz

TE - Gary Barnidge, Jeff King, Dante Rosario

RDE - Julius Peppers, Everett Brown, Hilee Taylor

UT - Damione Lewis, Corey Irvin

NT - TRADE/RELEASED PLAYER, Marlon Favorite

LDE - Tyler Brayton, Charles Johnson

WLB - Thomas Davis, James Anderson

MLB - Jon Beason, Dan Connor, J Leman

SLB - Na'il Diggs, Dan Connor, Landon Johnson

CB - Richard Marshall, Captain Munnerlyn

CB - Chris Gamble, Sherrod Martin

FS - Charles Godfrey, Quentin Teal

SS - Chris Harris, Dante Wesley

Defense, 25

Punter - Jason Baker

PK - John Kasay

Kickoffs - Rhys Lloyd

Long Snapper - J. J. Jansenn

[Carolina Crazy V2]

So far, this is who looks like they deserve to be on there:

OFFENSE:

WR1: Steve Smith - Dwayne Jarrett - Ryne Robinson

LT: Jordan Gross

LG: Travelle Wharton - Justin Geisinger

C: Ryan Kalil - Mackenzy Bernadeau

RG: Keydrick Vincent - Duke Robinson (DP)

RT: Jeff Otah

TE: Gary Barnidge - Jeff King - Dante Rosario

WR2: Muhsin Muhammad - Kenneth Moore

QB: Jake Delhomme - Matt Moore - Josh McCown

FB: Brad Hoover - Tony Fiammetta (DP)

RB: DeAngelo Williams - Jonathan Stewart - Mike Goodson (DP)

DEFENSE:

LE: Tyler Brayton - Charles Johnson

DLT: Nick Hayden - Marlon Favorite

DRT: Damione Lewis - Corvey Irvin (DP)

RE: Julius Peppers - Everette Brown (DP) - Hilee Taylor

SLB: Na'il Diggs - Jeremy Leman - Landon Johnson

MLB: Jon Beason - Dan Connor

WLB: Thomas Davis - James Anderson

LCB: Chris Gamble - C.J. Wilson - Sherrod Martin (DP)

RCB: Richard Marshall - Dante Wesley - Captain Munnerlyn (DP)

SS: Chris Harris - Quinton Teal

FS: Charles Godfrey

SPECIAL TEAMS:

K: John Kasay - Rhys Lloyd

P: Jason Baker - Rhys Lloyd

KO: Rhys Lloyd - John Kasay

H: Jason Baker

DS: J.J. Jansen - Gary Barnidge - Ryan Kalil

KR: Mike Goodson (DP) - Ryne Robinson - Captain Munnerlyn (DP) - Kenneth Moore

PR: Captain Munnerlyn (DP) - Ryne Robinson - Kenneth Moore - Mike Goodson (DP)

Geisinger apparently played LT in college and Macky played RG/RT. I think if Otah went down, Macky could play RT. I think if Gross went down, Wharton would go to LT and Duke at LG. However, if Wharton gets hurt and then Gross, I think Otah would slide in at LT with Duke at LG and Macky at RT. Geisinger would probably be a last resort at LT. Schwartz and Cadogan just haven't shown that they deserve a roster spot.

I agree except:

OFFENSE:

WR1: Steve Smith - Dwayne Jarrett - Larry Beavers (DP) / Ryne Robinson

LT: Jordan Gross

LG: Travelle Wharton - Justin Geisinger

C: Ryan Kalil - Mackenzy Bernadeau

RG: Keydrick Vincent - Duke Robinson (DP)

RT: Jeff Otah

TE: Gary Barnidge - Jeff King - Dante Rosario

WR2: Muhsin Muhammad - Kenneth Moore

QB: Jake Delhomme - Matt Moore - Hunter Cantwell (DP) / Josh McCown

FB: Brad Hoover - Tony Fiammetta (DP)

RB: DeAngelo Williams - Jonathan Stewart - Mike Goodson (DP)

DEFENSE:

LE: Charles Johnson - Hilee Taylor

DLT: Tyler Brayton - Marlon Favorite / Nick Hayden

DRT: Damione Lewis - Corvey Irvin (DP)

RE: Julius Peppers - Everette Brown (DP)

SLB: Na'il Diggs - Jeremy Leman - Landon Johnson

MLB: Jon Beason - Dan Connor

WLB: Thomas Davis - James Anderson

LCB: Chris Gamble - C.J. Wilson - Sherrod Martin (DP)

RCB: Richard Marshall - Captain Munnerlyn (DP)

SS: Chris Harris - Dante Wesley

FS: Quinton Teal - Charles Godfrey

SPECIAL TEAMS:

K: John Kasay - Rhys Lloyd

P: Jason Baker

KO: Rhys Lloyd

H: Jason Baker

DS: J.J. Jansen - Gary Barnidge - Ryan Kalil

KR: Mike Goodson (DP) - Larry Beavers (DP) - Ryne Robinson - Kenneth Moore

PR: Captain Munnerlyn (DP) - Ryne Robinson - Larry Beavers (DP)

[Punisher]

Right now I think Irvin and Favorite need to start. It really hurts to say it.

[PantherBrew]

Since when has Godfrey been benched?

[magnus]

I have about the same, though a depth chart is useless at TE. I see King and Rosario still getting more snaps and each getting some starts, it depends on the package. Last week those two started the game together.

[rayzor]

QB - Jake Delhomme, Matt Moore, Josh McCown

RB - DeAngelo Williams, Jonathan Stewart, Mike Goodson

FB - Brad Hoover, Tony Fiametta

WR - Steve Smith, Kenny Moore, Ryne Robinson

WR - Muhsin Muhammad, Dwayne Jarrett

LT - Jordan Gross, Travelle Wharton

LG - Travelle Wharton, Mackenzie Bernadeau

C - Ryan Kalil, Mackenzie Bernadeau

RG - Keydrick Vincent, Duke Robinson

RT - Jeff Otah, Geoff Schwartz

TE - Gary Barnidge, Jeff King, Dante Rosario

25

RDE - Julius Peppers, Everett Brown, Hilee Taylor

UT - Damione Lewis, Corvey Irvin

NT - Marlon Favorite, Nick Hayden

LDE - Tyler Brayton, Charles Johnson

WLB - Thomas Davis, James Anderson

MLB - Jon Beason, Dan Connor

SLB - Na'il Diggs, J Leman, Landon Johnson

CB - Richard Marshall, Captain Munnerlyn

CB - Chris Gamble, CJ Wilson

FS - Charles Godfrey, Quentin Teal

SS - Chris Harris, Dante Wesley

Punter - Jason Baker

PK - John Kasay

Kickoffs - Rhys Lloyd

Long Snapper - J. J. Jansen

landon johnson is pissing me off. i had to choose between him and sherrod martin. even though sherrod has yet to show why he is worth that pick i'd rather have him than johnson. johnson's contract is the only reason he will have a roster spot.

that being said, i wouldn't be surprised to see him put on the IR list. it would be a waste of money but i would rather use that spot on the roster with someone who has potential to be good rather than potential to get hurt.

[firstdayfan]

I like it a lot however nothing much has changed since before the first preseason game. I think J Leman has played his way onto the team and CJ Wilson might be the odd man out. As far as the offensive line depth goes I think if Otah ever missed any extensive time then Wharton would take over at left tackle and gross would take Otah's spot and Bernadeau would start at LG. If Gross went down the Wharton would kick out to left tackle and Bernadeau would take over. If Kalil goes down, Bernadeau, and if Vincent goes down it would be Robinson. IF Otah and Gross were to go down then Wharton would play left tackle, Bernadeau would play Left Guard and probably Schwartz or may even Duke Robinson would kick out to tackle. Its nice to have such versatile offensive linemen. It would take a few injuries to really hurt the line, which could definitely happen the way this season is going. I'm really worried about the injury issue with Stewart, I think he might need to take a season off and get healthy although I would hate to ever see that happen.

[SCMunnerlyn1]

Munnerlyn takes the nickel and punt return spot