Panthers with 3 on SI all rookie team, KB not one

[ctrcat]

http://www.si.com/nfl/2014/12/23/best-nfl-rookies-2014-teddy-bridgewater-aaron-donald

Ealy, Turner, Bene. Truly unreal. GGGGGGGGMan!!!!

[Lilsmitty09]

haha what?!?! No offense to Turner and Ealy, but KB is much more deserving of it. Just tells you how deep the WR class was and how shallow the G and DE class was.

Whatevs, it's really just ones opinion, and SI's at that.

[csx]

haha what?!?! No offense to Turner and Ealy, but KB is much more deserving of it. Just tells you how deep the WR class was and how shallow the G and DE class was.

Whatevs, it's really just ones opinion, and SI's at that.

 

Kevin Benjamin isn't competing against Turner and Ealy for this list. He's competing against other rookie wide receivers.

[ctrcat]

^ Don't disagree but GeniusMan is the real story here.

[mav1234]

Evans and KB are very close, so I don't really slight the author for not having 'em both on there, given Beckham's incredible season.

[Guest Barry McCaulkinor]

Someone's a moron...

 

errrr I'm wrong. 

[PantherWake]

Trai hasn't allowed a sack all season?! Thats incredible and he's only 21...

[Lilsmitty09]

Kevin Benjamin isn't competing against Turner and Ealy for this list. He's competing against other rookie wide receivers.

 

Which is why I brought up how deep the WR class is and shallow the G and DE class is....

[Mark S]

Gman is the man

[Udogg]

haha what?!?! No offense to Turner and Ealy, but KB is much more deserving of it. Just tells you how deep the WR class was and how shallow the G and DE class was.

Whatevs, it's really just ones opinion, and SI's at that.

 

Benjamin play Guard, DE and Corner back?

 

If the argument is KB should have made it over Mike Evans, that's definitely debatable.   OBJ is not even an argument anymore, they engraved his Offensive Rookie Trophy on Sunday.  

[Captain Morgan]

from the article

 

I had Turner pegged as one of the more underrated linemen in the 2014 draft class -- he was projected by many as a middle-round prospect (the Panthers took him in the third round), but every time I watched his LSU tape, it seemed that there were bodies flying everywhere. He hasn't allowed a single sack in 618 snaps, which speaks to his improved pass-blocking.

[SCP]

Norwell should be on that list

[MtnJax]

[Montsta]

For those that saw the other thread where I said I don't like Trai because he hasn't re-signed with the Panthers in my Madden franchise:

I franchised him twice and he still wouldn't sign. Signed a MASSIVE contract with the Titans. fug that guy.

But in real life we're good.