Acceptable Thanksgiving Pies

[SCP]

Perhaps we should consult the American Pie Council

http://www.piecouncil.org/

*when I retire I am seeking a chair on this council

[BettyBangzer]

I concur with Igo's list, although I would omit cherry only because it sucks in comparison to the others listed.

As far as fruit based pies go

Apple>Blueberry>strawberry>lemon>Cherry

I don't know what a rhubarb is.

 

Strawberry rhubarb pie is pretty damn good (at least the way my grandma made it). But of course, it's a summer pie.

[SCP]

Their slogan is "Grab a slice of Life." So fugging perfect.

[csx]

Blackberry is about as Pilgrim and Indian as it gets.

 

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

Pecans are poo

[Byrdman4real]

I have never been a fan of pumpkin pie or sweet potato pie.

Both flavors take over the pie crust. Both would be better served in some kind of sweet casserole.

Man I love both, plus Apple

Slap some ice cream on it and I become a kid again

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

And no raspberry pie? Nope nope nope

[DanTheMan]

It's not a real pie, it falls into the novelty pie category and is not welcome at a true Americans Thanksgiving

How do you know? Were you there at the first Thanksgiving?

[Kakarot]

Pumpkin is ok; depends on who makes it or where you get it from. My grandma has to make 3 sweet potato pies when I come visit for thanksgiving, because she knows I'll usually go through one myself. Also, apple pie with some ice cream. Good lawd!

[SCP]

Pecans are poo

I will beat your ass

[Panthro]

cherry pie tastes like an abortion clinic dumpster that has missed a few weeks of pick ups.

[DanTheMan]

Here, let me take a watery dump in a pastry shell, someone will call it a pie.

Two dudes and a pie?

[Panthro]

Blackberry is about as Pilgrim and Indian as it gets.

Someone watches top chef

[Panthro]

I made these the other day

 

http://paleogrubs.com/pumpkin-pie-energy-bites-recipe

 

delicioso