Over the last 3 weeks, Mike Shula's offense has averaged less points...

[bandu]

How could we possibly bring in a new OC at this point in time and try to learn a new playbook and even be able to execute it properly is beyond me.unless in fact their playbook resembles one like SCP showed us earlier,lol, or we could promote who,because i sure cant think of anyone..so,all this fire Shula is pretty much a moot point at this point.

[bandu]

btw,Shulas numbers are are sooo srewed and skewed in large part to DGs inability to scout oL talent and does anyone actually think any OC could or would be successful in this particular situation?if so,well then please enlighten me?

[Mol3m4n]

btw,Shulas numbers are are sooo srewed and skewed in large part to DGs inability to scout oL talent and does anyone actually think any OC could or would be successful in this particular situation?if so,well then please enlighten me?

Same post in every thread. 90% of people agree that Shula is a problem and needs to go. You don't have to look at execution to judge a coordinator, but instead play call, situational awareness, game plan change, taking advantage of a weakness, and play design. Shula is bad at all of those. I don't have to see it executed to know that his play has a high percent to fail before it is even ran.

[panthers55]

Same post in every thread. 90% of people agree that Shula is a problem and needs to go. You don't have to look at execution to judge a coordinator, but instead play call, situational awareness, game plan change, taking advantage of a weakness, and play design. Shula is bad at all of those. I don't have to see it executed to know that his play has a high percent to fail before it is even ran.

And 90% of the huddle posters are college students who never played football and have no idea what they are talking about.  Unless you know what play was called and what should have happened or what adjustments pre and post snap should have been made you have no idea what was supposed to happen simply what did.  That gives you little awareness of any of the factors you mentioned.  How many times did Shula call one play but Newton audibeled to something else.. You dont have a clue.  Like most of the huddle it doesn't stop you from being an armchair expert..

[Snake]

Chud offense through his first 25 games as an OC scored a total of 552 points.

Shula's offense through this past game or his first 25 games as OC scored a total of 547 points which is 2 tenths of a point per game difference.

But Chud was great and Shula's sucks right????

Errrr can they both suck? Cause that's the case, neither were great game planners.

[SZ James (banned)]

so is this dude really defending shula?

[panthers55]

so is this dude really defending shula?

I am just presenting the facts.  Something in short supply around here this season .Everyone can make their own assessment.  But now you have actual numbers and facts instead of speculation and the old eyeball test which is considered the gold standard here but in other arenas like eyewitness testimony is considered highly unreliable.

[panthers55]

Errrr can they both suck? Cause that's the case, neither were great game planners.

So when did we have an OC who didn't suck??  We have rarely had great offenses.

[bandu]

Same post in every thread. 90% of people agree that Shula is a problem and needs to go. You don't have to look at execution to judge a coordinator, but instead play call, situational awareness, game plan change, taking advantage of a weakness, and play design. Shula is bad at all of those. I don't have to see it executed to know that his play has a high percent to fail before it is even ran.

and i agree that Shula needs to be replaced after this season because i dont believe and once again,that he is the right OC to develop Cam Newton.However,i believe any OC would struggle trying to execute their offense with this oL of ours;so explain to me,how can any offense possibly not struggle with the inability to block?.have you seen whats happened against this oL with just a 3 man rush or the end of the Seattle game or Greg Olsen having to be primarily used as a blocker here of late?so YES,i absolutley 100% think this offense will struggle no matter what,until the oL is addressed.

btw,i corrected the word "too" since it cant be replaced with "also" nor does it indicate excessiveness before a verb but in this case it could possibly indicate excessiveness one might argue,either or,geeze, just chill out with the adolescent grammar nit picking and lets just stick with the subject of Mike Shula or football in general,Mo13m4n.and look at your spelling instead of mine "jusr" saying,

[Mol3m4n]

and i agree that Shula needs to be replaced after this season because i dont believe and once again,that he is the right OC to develop Cam Newton.However,i believe any OC would struggle trying to execute their offense with this oL of ours;so explain to me,how can any offense possibly not struggle with the inability too block?.have you seen whats happened against this oL with just a 3 man rush or the end of the Seattle game or Greg Olsen having to be primarily used as a blocker here of late?so YES,i absolutley 100% think this offense will struggle no matter what,until the oL is addressed.

You aren't going to win every game with this line, but you should at least game plan around it. It has not been done. I am as much of an arm chair expert as you are, so that claim is jusr pointless. I kind of just skimmed your post because you used the wrong form of "to". However, I can see what play is called, and Cam Newton does not audible every play. I know when a run is called on 3rd and 17 in the red zone. I may not be an expert, but I have watched and played more football in my life than I can even remember, so I think my opinion and anyone else's should hold as much value as yours. Usually a majority of 90% isn't wrong.

Bad line or not, Shula can be judged and needs to be fired. Cam is scrutinized for hours play behind a bad line, so why can't a Shula?

[Mojo]

As a Panther fan and believer in Cam Newton, I just want our coaching staff to give us the best opportunity to win. I don't believe Mike Shula is a great option. The combination of Shula and Rivera is too vanilla and old school imo. Of course he doesn't need to be fired now. That would be a disaster. But in the offseason his job does need to be evaluated. This has been his mo since he was a college coach. Uber conservative play calling. Bad red zone efficiency. It's not all his fault but I don't see how anyone can defend him so vehemently.

[ThinkAboutIt]

Things are going to get worse before they get better.

 

Not unless Cam Newton gets injured, God forbid. If he stays healthy, it can only get better than the last 3 weeks. 

[beastson]

Urban definition of homer

 

Someone who shows blind loyalty to a team or organization, typically ignoring any shortcomings or faults they have.

 

 

[bandu]

A realist is someone who can see things for what they are,not what they are told they are.