MNF: Indianapolis Colts (3-4) at NY Giants (5-3)

[CelibatePimp]

Lol @ the challenge, he did not get the first down I think.

[Thal]

True. However, you can't do that with every QB. The fact that he 4 TD's and doesn't have a pick yet after throwing that many times already is incredible.

2 dropped INTs by the Giants' defense.

[WhoAmI?]

2 dropped INTs by the Giants' defense.

 

Yep, but should of, could of int's don't go into the statbook.

[CelibatePimp]

TY Hilton is now the leading receiver in the league. 3rd round pick.

[WhoAmI?]

Even though I like Luck and he is one hell of a QB, the suckfest from Dilfer and Steve Young is annoying as f*ck.

[Marc Anthony]

Luck or Cam, if you had a choice, who would you pick?

[WhoAmI?]

TY Hilton is now the leading receiver in the league. 3rd round pick.

 

Too bad we didn't have a 3rd round pick in 2012 lol Oh well, we wouldn't have taken him anyway. Hilton's a stud. Reminds me a lot of Antonio Brown. Undersized, but quick as hell, can make people miss, and makes tough catches. If he continues to develop, he could very well end up like him.

 

[Thal]

If 438 yards, 2 TD's and 2 int's is brutal, then that just shows you how good Peyton is. And I don't believe that QB's performances are dependent on the players around them. Brady had absolutely nobody last year and still got his team to the divisional championship. And I wouldn't call Richardson, Bradshaw, Hilton, Nicks, and Fleener a very great supporting cast. Good? Absolutely. Great? Absolutely not. They have a decent bunch. Now the Bears, that's an elite supporting cast. Too bad Cutler sucks ass.

Then, who the hell is catching those passes and running 20 yards with them? What more would you want from WRs that gets open and catch passes?

Peyton's stat were just catch stats against soft defense.

[CelibatePimp]

Wow, Luck already has 3,085 yds passing. LOL

[WhoAmI?]

Luck or Cam, if you had a choice, who would you pick?

 

Pretty obvious if you ask me. Luck is a better passer and can run just as good as Cam. No knock on Cam, Luck is just that good.

[CelibatePimp]

Luck or Cam, if you had a choice, who would you pick?

 

Is this like a trick question? No one will pick Cam over Luck now.

[Thal]

Yep, but should of, could of int's don't go into the statbook.

As long as the stat book is the only thing that counts.

[WhoAmI?]

Then, who the hell is catching those passes and running 20 yards with them? What more would you want from WRs that gets open and catch passes?

Peyton's stat were just catch stats against soft defense.

 

I know it doesn't seem like it because our offense is so bad, but WR's getting open and actually catching passes is pretty normal in the NFL.

 

[Thal]

Luck or Cam, if you had a choice, who would you pick?

I'm a Cam fan and I would pick Luck right now. Cam hasn't show us some flash in a long time now. I understand the issues around him but you can't be too dependent on what's around you either.