J.J. Watt or Luke Kuechly

[PantherKyle]

You're a homer if you say Kuechly, honestly. 

[Thal]

Greg Hardy

Best freaking answer. With the texans being ranked 26th defensively can't really tell if Watt is a factor at all. Question is, would they be a 25th ranked defense without Watt.

And the again, who cares. Neither is much of a factor for their respective defense.

[CelticCat]

Watt. He takes over games by himself. I've only seen Luke completely take over a game once, and that was last year against the Saints at home to win the division.

 

Did you miss the entire 2013 season? The Texans had the #1 pick in the draft.

 

This is a team game. I thought the Steelers and Ravens taught us that.

 

If I was a GM and had the chance to build my franchise around either player I'd consider myself a very lucky man.

[SmokinwithWilly]

We've spent enough money on DE's.

 

Gimme Luke.

[Ergent Seth]

Luke. younger, hasnt even reached his peak, affects more plays.

[Eazy-E]

JJ Watt is a beast but His team went 2-14 with him leading that defense. Just shows that one player can't do it all himself. Even this year Houston has some pretty good players on defense but overall their team stats are pretty bad.

I also don't know if Watt can really even improve at his position anymore. Luke is still getting better in coverage and rushing the Passer while already winning the dpoy.

Lukes stock is still on the rise as to where I believe Watts has steadied

[TheNewStandard]

Watt is a friggin uber-dork. Gosh I hate that dance commercial with the David Carr gloves. Oh my if I only had a disintegration ray gun and a never ending supply of disposable TVs.

[Ken]

Tough choice but I'll take Watt.

[Hammerin'Cameron34]

What is the love affair with Watt, please, do tell

 

Hardy has never sniffed a DPoY but Id say the two are similar, very similar and i'd take Luke all day over Watt y'all are crazy lol LUKE

 

If I was flipping a coin and one side was Watt and one side was Hardy, it would be like one side is 20 million bucks and the other side is 18 million bucks 

[Brooklyn Bully]

Whoever is younger and less injury prone.

[Brooklyn Bully]

What is the love affair with Watt, please, do tell

 

Hardy has never sniffed a DPoY but Id say the two are similar, very similar and i'd take Luke all day over Watt y'all are crazy lol LUKE

 

If I was flipping a coin and one side was Watt and one side was Hardy, it would be like one side is 20 million bucks and the other side is 18 million bucks 

 

Your HOMER is showing. Tuck it back in.

[Peppers90 NC]

2-14 had nothing to do with their pathetic offense last year now did it?  All Watt's fault?  Some of you dudes are just nuts.

[AU-panther]

Watt.

If elite MLBs are more important then elite DEs why do football people choose to pay DEs more.

[The_Mango55]

Watt, easy.

 

Love Luke but Watt might be the best player in football, and is certainly the most valuable non QB.