Kelvin Benjamin named NFL Offensive Rookie for September

[CatMan72]

#Gettlemagic

[mc52beast]

Wait a minute... this guy was picked 28th? What about all those other guys picked in front of him who were going to "light the NFL on fire"???

[Chief Keek]

Third ROY within 4 years?

 

[B.BERSIN]

Back to the time Gman made the pick, I was excited that we picked him at the first sight, but I just had some concern about his experience after a second thought, so yeah now I'm very much convinced.

[Rise of The Hive]

Congrats Kelvin!

[SIGCHI222]

Third ROY within 3 years?

 

 

You....you might wanna check that numbers thingy you got going on there.

 

 

But your enthusiasm is duly noted.

 

[MedellinHeel]

It was hard to understand why he was so low in the mock drafts. I only saw KB in the Clemson - FSU game and just a little in the title game.  Did he have several bad games in the interim? Because it was clear to anybody watching he was going to be an NFL stud just based on those two games.

 

KB was knocked due to drops, lack of elite speed, and a pedestrian vertical. 

 

So essentially no Megatron type player. Taking a slight gamble with him and hope he turns into a great possession / redzone WR. 

[SIGCHI222]

KB was knocked due to drops, lack of elite speed, and a pedestrian vertical. 

 

So essentially no Megatron type player. Taking a slight gamble with him and hope he turns into a great possession / redzone WR. 

 

Drops...has had a few but apparently not an issue or coachable by the Master Ricky considering his recent awards.

 

Elite speed...see Jerry Rice and above statement.

 

Pedestrian vertical....SS#89 jumping 36" inches off the ground equals KB standing on his tip toes.

 

Why you hate so much on this team and yet spend so many useless hours on here is beyond anyone, including me.

 

I'll leave you with these.

 

[MedellinHeel]

Drops...has had a few but apparently not an issue or coachable by the Master Ricky considering his recent awards.

 

Elite speed...see Jerry Rice and above statement.

 

Pedestrian vertical....SS#89 jumping 36" inches off the ground equals KB standing on his tip toes.

 

Why you hate so much on this team and yet spend so many useless hours on here is beyond anyone, including me.

 

I'll leave you with these.

 

 

Discussing his shortcomings or giving excuses is another topic altogether. 

 

Someone wanted to know why KB was not a top pick. I listed those reasons. 

 

Not sure why you have your panties up in a wad. 

 

Everything I said was FACTS to KB's draft negatives

 

Drop problem - check 

No elite speed - check

Peristrain vert - check

 

None of which means he cant be a great player. Even without speed or a vert he can still be a nightmare with his size as a possession and jump ball WR. He just will never really be able to take the top off the D on top of the other things like Megatron can. But not many people can do all that anyway. 

 

Why do I hate on this team? 

 

Why do you confuse hating with merely discussion things without homer glasses? 

 

I love the Panthers and for the record I love KB. 

 

I was worried about the pick at first as he was raw with the issues I mentioned, but he has certainly proved the doubters wrong up until now. 

 

In fact right after the draft, I said I would have taken KB at 28 knowing off the OT's that would still be on the board later in the draft. 

 

The only "hating" I do on this forum is for Shula. In which it is deserved. 

[Who Said What?]

The future is now!

 

[B.BERSIN]

Why do you confuse hating with merely discussion things without homer glasses?

Someone will just jump the gun when they hear any negative comments about players they love, even when those comments are just others quoted ideas.

[FootballMaestro]

Someone will just jump the gun when they hear any negative comments about players they love, even when those comments are just others quoted ideas.

 

No Medellin Heal was a HATER, and whined on and on after the Panthers picked Benjamin,, even weeks later and during the season. So don't buy his act. 

 

I won't even take the time or effort to illustrate why the things he listed wouldn't necessarily make a player drop, and what was more specific for Kelvin Benjamin, and why he could/would drop.

 

But it doesn't matter.

 

[MedellinHeel]

No Medellin Heal was a HATER, and whined on and on after the Panthers picked Benjamin,, even weeks later and during the season. So don't buy his act. 

 

I won't even take the time or effort to illustrate why the things he listed wouldn't necessarily make a player drop, and what was more specific for Kelvin Benjamin, and why he could/would drop.

 

But it doesn't matter.

 

 

Lets see, 

 

 

Yea I really didnt like KB. So much that I had him in my dream mock in the FIRST round. 

 

Additionally, I had him in my draft redo. 

 

 

lolz

 

#fail

[psyburn21]

Congrats to KB!!! Keep up the great work.