Punt Returner Free Agents

[top dawg]

Nothing against Philly, but I don't want to spend the whole season holding my breath on every kick return.  I'm not buying that he needs more practice.  You can either catch with consistency, or you can't.  Returning is not new to the kid.  

[TheRed]

Name a decent return man that started off his career looking like poo? You either can or can't at that spot.

 

What's your definition of "looking like poo"?

 

How about this, give the guy at least one regular season game before declaring him a complete bust huh?

[TheRed]

Also, again I'll ask, since people are acting like he's got lost fumbles like crazy, how many did he not recover?

[KillerKat]

I'm comparing someone that plays the same position as someone else to someone that plays the same position as someone else? Wut?

You can't compare quarterbacks to returners. The reasons have already been stated.

You can't bring up a complete dumbass comparison (the one you just brought in) to try to argue against a very legit one (mine). It doesn't make your argument any better.

Right now, I just think you two just like to play dumb just to keep the argument going.

[Mol3m4n]

You can't compare quarterbacks to returners. The reasons have already been stated.

You can't bring up a complete dumbass comparison (the one you just brought in) to try to argue against a very legit one (mine). It doesn't make your argument any better.

Right now, I just think you two just like to play dumb just to keep the argument going.

I'm comparing a returner to a returner. I'm comparing a quarterback to a quarterback. You need to learn the composition of analogies.

[top dawg]

Also, again I'll ask, since people are acting like he's got lost fumbles like crazy, how many did he not recover?

 

Surely you aren't justifying dumb luck as a positive?

 

That's rhetorical.

[KillerKat]

Also, again I'll ask, since people are acting like he's got lost fumbles like crazy, how many did he not recover?

With the shape of the ball, the recovery doesn't matter since the ball could very well just bounce into the other team's hands. You're arguing a point that is based solely on the luck of a bounce. We can't continue to rely on luck during the regular season.

[TheRed]

Surely you aren't justifying dumb luck as a positive.

 

You can call it luck or whatever, did he recover them all or not?

[TheRed]

Well I'm done. If you want to sit around and mope and convince yourselves that we are doomed, by all means go ahead.

[KillerKat]

I'm comparing a returner to a returner. I'm comparing a quarterback to a quarterback. You need to learn the composition of analogies.

You need to understand what I'm trying to tell you. You can't compare 2 QBs to try to argue against the comparison of 2 PRs. You also need to learn the difference between the 2 positions as well. QB is a position you can learn. The norm for returners is they have it or don't.

[CRA]

What's your definition of "looking like poo"?

 

How about this, give the guy at least one regular season game before declaring him a complete bust huh?

Tonight

Why give him a regular season game. Isn't the purpose of preseason so you don't knowingly do unwise things when it matters?

[CarolinaSamurai]

With the shape of the ball, the recovery doesn't matter since the ball could very well just bounce into the other team's hands. You're arguing a point that is based solely on the luck of a bounce. We can't continue to rely on luck during the regular season.

I don't think you like Philly Brown as a person. You talk like he stole your lunch money.

Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

[top dawg]

You can call it luck or whatever, did he recover them all or not?

 

That's not even the point. He shouldn't have had to recover them.  

 

You know that the NFL games can hinge upon mistakes on kicks.  He is consistently bobbling the ball.  Just because he is recovering muffs today doesn't mean he'll recover them tomorrow. 

[Kakarot]

Nothing against Philly, but I don't want to spend the whole season holding my breath on every kick return.  I'm not buying that he needs more practice.  You can either catch with consistency, or you can't.  Returning is not new to the kid.  

This.