Would you trade Anderson to St Louis?

[Ivan The Awesome]

I'd trade Joe Webb first. Anderson is too valuable to US than to the Rams. 

[nosuchthingasapanther]

even before news of newton's rib injury my answer would have been no.

the panthers can win with anderson.

webb...i'm not sold on at all.

[chknwing]

YES! If Cam goes down don't fool your self no one is coming in to save the season. Back Qbs are only good to hold the fort down, not make playoff runs.

 

tell jake delhomme that

[Jeremy Igo]

tell jake delhomme that

Zing.

Sent from Carolina Huddle App for Android.

[tondi]

I think we'd still be competitive with Anderson at QB.  He's a former Pro Bowler and has been in the offense for 4 seasons now.  Of course you lose that big play scrambling capability Cam brings to the table but I don't think we'd be 4-12 with Anderson starting at QB.  

 

You may be right but I don't think a 6-10 season would be out of the question with DA starting every game.  Doesn't mean I think he sucks or anything but since I would imagine most around here would be happy with us winning 10-11 games I certainly think Cam is worth an additional 4-5 wins over his backup.  I used the 4 win scenario for if we got rid of DA and went with somebody like Webb and I could definitely see that happening as well, although hopefully we wouldn't sink quite that low.

[stratopanther]

there's only one thing i love more than my strat

IMG_20140529_201006_328.jpg

That's nice man she looks like a screamer. I dig les pauls especially flamed maple ones.

[2jakefansinva]

we don't have any back-up QB's that anyone in their right mind would be asking about.

[propagandamachine]

GO FOR IT> 

[micnificent28]

But trade him for the sake trading? We aren't going to get anything to improve our team this year

In my opinion It's like the beason trade last year. We didn't get anything for it that was worth it but something is better than nothing for a guy that is just insurance. I'm sure we could work out some player trade.

[Kevin Greene]

If we trade away DA and don't make another move to replace him we may as well plan on having DWill run the Wildcat full time.

[Panthro]

Skins should deal Cousins....they likely could get something really good for him.

Actually they should deal rg3 bit that's another thread

[KendrickPanther]

I really don't know why anyone thins Derek Anderson is trade bait. He begged Cleveland to sign him. They declined in favor of Brandon Weedon and Brian Hoyer. Everyone outside of Charlotte thinks DA is one of the worst backups in the league. 

 

He fits the Panthers because he gets along with Cam and has veteran insight. Nobody is trading anything for DA. 

[MV%doe]

Id trade anyone- cam luke etc if you meet my needs and wants. For DA at his current contract, id want at least a third rounder and a OT prospect. I greatly value DA and would hate moving given what he's done @ cheap sal plus he's a new father. So id need that third and OT to do something I really don't want to do.

[Matthias]

I like DA.  Yet if we can trade him back to Cleveland for Joe Thomas, that would work.  I know Thomas couldn't wait to get out of that sorry place.