Ranking the NFC South QBs

[PhillyB]

objectively speaking, brees is better than cam.

 

cam is probably neck-and-neck with matt ryan.

 

cam is on the ascent while matt ryan and drew brees have already peaked, so in terms of the future cam is the best.

 

mike glennon looks like a pez dispenser and i can't stop laughing at his fumble against us last year

 

at this particular moment:

 

1) brees

2) cam

3) ryan

4) pez dispenser

 

considering the future:

 

1) cam

2) ryan

3) brees

4) pez dispenser

[iamhubby1]

IMO, Brees has had a HOF type career. He still has some gas in the tank. So I would still put him first.

Cam in going to have a HOF career. But...he isn't there quite yet. He is still better than Matty Sh/t in my pants.

TB...not even in the conversation.

[RelaxImaPro]

It goes Brees > Cam > Ryan >>>> Tampa Bay QB.

 

Brees looked like he started the decline a bit last year.  He's always had an inflated completion % and yardage total due to using the screen game as a makeshift running game... not mentioning the games they have every year where they stat pad in games that are already decided.  Payton and Brees are probably the worst I've ever seen at that stat-padding poo.  They're obsessed with looking good on the stat sheet.

 

Yeah, I bet Cam could've thrown for 30 TDs, maybe had a couple more rushing TDs and 500 or more yards if we didn't play kill-the-clock so many times last season.  Giants game, Vikings game, Rams game, 1st Falcons game, and both Bucs games.  That's 6 fuging games we could've stat-padded like a mofo if we really wanted to.  We know what Brees and Payton would've done given that same scenario.  Minimum of 5 TDs and 400+ for ole moleboy before the game ends.

 

That's one reason why the end of that week 17 game against the Saints was so sweet in the 2012 season.  Drove the entire length of the field and could've easily dropped 50+ on them if we wanted the way were moving the ball, but instead we took a knee at their goal line.  Sent a big "fug you" to both of them.

[OneBadCat]

I think Cam is the best QB in the NFC South. Yes I said it, even over Drew Candyass.  Brees is already showing decline. Am I the only that noticed the dude throwing floaters last year? 

 

Maybe it's just because we are really good at kicking the Saints ass but every time the Saints play a close game Brees ends up being a liability rather than someone to lean on. I mean the past few years the Panthers can lay claim to several crucial interceptions that change the game all because we pressured Brees. He's a stat padding cry baby and I won't respect him just because he's in a offense that makes him look better than he is. 

 

Oh and Matt Ryan sucks.

 

 

 

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

Lol, you know where this is going don't you?

Ryan is above average while Cam is at the threshold of great and just a stones throw from being legendary.

This message is brought to you by The Best Huddle App ever made.

 

Would this stone happen to be Uluru?

Cam is on the verge of being a top 10 QB, if he does well again next season

[Jackofalltrades]

Statistically Ryan has been better. Last year was his fist with a losing recond, his completion percentage is better, his TD:INT is better, he's know for late game come backs.

Cam will wind up better, clearly has more talent, but Ryan has the numbers at this point.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G900A using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[L-TownCat]

Would this stone happen to be Uluru?

Cam is on the verge of being a top 10 QB, if he does well again next season

I don't know what that means. However, Cam is on the path of being one of the greats while Ryan has hit his ceiling.

Sent from my iPad using CarolinaHuddle

[Lumps]

I think Cam is the best QB in the NFC South. Yes I said it, even over Drew Candyass.

Lol

God you guys are embarrassing.

[B.BERSIN]

The quarterbacks who play for the Panthers would always be the no.1 in my heart.

[Growl]

Ryan has never been able to shoulder Atlanta's offense the way that has Newton has done for ours. The burden on each of their shoulders is incomparable. Not to mention the surrounding players, and the age difference, I take Newton over Ryan every single time without hesitation.

[Growl]

And if NFL players have any bit of credibility in evaluation, they do as well.

[Ergent Seth]

Caamm oooohh camm

Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

[h0llywood]

If throwing for 5,000 yards, 104 passer rating is considered on the decline then when are all fugged. 

[h0llywood]

Matt Ryan through his outstanding* first 3 seasons is similar statistically to Andy Dalton. I don't know why the urge to have Dalton on the hot seat when Matty Rice was putting up the same results. I will pass on him being #2.

 

Matt Ryan Average Through First Three Seasons

 

CMP      ATT            %             Yards            TD        INT           RAT
295       485.33       60.63       3353.66          22       11.3          86.5

 

Matt Ryan First three Playoffs - 0W - 3L

 

Andy Dalton Average Through First Three Seasons

 

CMP        ATT            %             Yards          TD        INT           RAT

330.66    543.33     60.76      3786.66         26.6      16.3          85.53

Andy Dalton Playoff  Record - 0W - 3L