Most Underrated Game of All-Time

[iamcline]

Inspired by KillerKat's "Most Overrated" Game thread.  What are your thoughts on the most Underrated?  To me it's Red Dead Redemption.  Such an epic of a game, a lot of people turned away from it because it was "western".

[cardiackat88.]

WWF No Mercy.

 

A super badass wrestling game!!!

[iamcline]

WWF No Mercy.

 

A super badass wrestling game!!!

 

I was one of the unfortunate ones who received a bad cartridge when I purchased it.  The one with with the faulty battery backup.  That was no fun.

[cardiackat88.]

I was one of the unfortunate ones who received a bad cartridge when I purchased it.  The one with with the faulty battery backup.  That was no fun.

 

You played it eventually though, right?

 

I have tried to play wrestling games since it and they just all suck ass in comparison.

[Porn Shop Clerk]

just about any tim schafer game

[iamcline]

You played it eventually though, right?

 

I have tried to play wrestling games since it and they just all suck ass in comparison.

 

Oh yeah, I still played it.  I enjoyed the hell out of it.  Still prefer Wrestlemania 2000 to No Mercy, but it was a blast.

[shreddingdefense]

Legend of dragoon

 

I play it once a year, never get sick of it. Deserved to be played by more people. Goes unnoticed due to ps2 was right around the courner, was not a squaresoft (now squareenix) rpg, or people were sick of rpgs by the time it came out. 

 

 

[OneBadCat]

I really liked the Croc games for playstation 1.

[TANTRIC-NINJA]

Dig dug

[PandaPancake]

Pokemon: Fire Red

Sent from my XT1080 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[Doc Holiday]

I second the legend of dragoon and Red dead revolver.

Halo 4 (probably the best of all the Halo's) gets a bad wrap for just being another halo game while probably being the best in the franchise. at the least it's #2 to H1.

[SOJA]

nhl hitz 2002

[Chimera]

Mike Tyson's Punch-Out. After nearly 30 years, 4 or 5 generations, countless technological advances... its still the best boxing game ever.

 

Also Red Dead Redemption, while being an epic game that didn't get a whole lot of talk, definitely didn't get underrated by critics. They were pretty unanimous that it was a great game.

 

eta: wow I forgot Oddworld: Abe's Exoddus. I literally could not put that game down.

[Donald LaFell]

Midtown Madness for PC. DAMN that game was fun. The open world environment for racing was ahead of it's time in my ill informed opinion.