NFL.com article-Peppers best player in team history.

[Pejorative Miscreant]

I can see it both ways. I vote for Smith because of his play coupled with longevity with the team. I view Pep as a better player overall. I think if both retired today Pep would get in the HOF and Smitty would not. Just my opinion though.

[CRA]

Smitty makes much more sense, especially when you throw in longevity.

Longevity wise doesn't really tilt things much....

Pep had production year after year after year. Yes, people wanted more....but he still had it. He had double digit stats year after year....and all kinds of other crazy stats like INTs, blocked kicks etc padded on those seasons.

Pep wins the stat debate especially when looking season after season.

89 the flare, heart, etc debates

[Fade2BlackAndBlue]

nah it has to be Chris Weinkie (sp?)

[CRA]

89 double digit TDs.....1 season

Pep double digit sacks....8 seasons (6 here)

That influences things outside the fanbase

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

That is just pure BS right there, Peppers is more dominant than any of those guys, and when their careers are all said and done, Peppers will have accomplished more than any.

 

i'm talking about the way it was discussed in the media not his specific worth as a player dumbass

 

how did your DPoY prediction for peppers work out by the way

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

Peppers 2004 season was by far better than Smiths 2005 season.

 

confirmed joke account

[Mr. Scot]

Longevity wise doesn't really tilt things much....

Pep had production year after year after year. Yes, people wanted more....but he still had it. He had double digit stats year after year....and all kinds of other crazy stats like INTs, blocked kicks etc padded on those seasons.

Pep wins the stat debate especially when looking season after season.

89 the flare, heart, etc debates

 

Are you looking at all time in the league or solely time with the Panthers?

 

Anytime we're talking about a 'best Panther' question, i exclude anything done outside of this team.

 

[Ruff]

You sir, are not very smart. I'm sure Peppers could accomplish all that he has in the NFL by "not caring". LOL

 

Says "not very smart"

Doesn't have reading comprehension.

 

My quote was in reference to what happened to Peppers' last year here when he didn't do anything (other than get benched during a high profile game).

 

Please, go back and read the comment before you hit reply. It'll save everyone the trouble of you making an ass of yourself. Dumbass.

[Ruff]

Apparently Julius Peppers has signed up for our forum and is trolling.

 

Wait, that's not possible... He has a "fake" UNC education, or whatever.

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

Says "not very smart"

Doesn't have reading comprehension.

 

My quote was in reference to what happened to Peppers' last year here when he didn't do anything (other than get benched during a high profile game).

 

Please, go back and read the comment before you hit reply. It'll save everyone the trouble of you making an ass of yourself. Dumbass.

 

hey hey that's enough!

 

you can troll the boards, you can spam entire articles from outside sources with no credit over and over again, but you do not use the "a" word

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/sports/football/nfl/2011-07-04-top-10-defensive-ends_n.htm

 

Yet last season Julius Peppers demonstrated he was fully capable of embodying Jones' notion of a complete defensive end during a career rebirth after signing with the Chicago Bears. Peppers was ranked as the game's best defensive end by USA TODAY Sports Weekly's panel of NFL writers and editors. Regarded primarily as a sack master during his first eight seasons with the Carolina Panthers, Peppers also was a force in shutting down opposing backfields in the Bears' 4-3 defensive alignment in 2010.

When Chicago raced to a 4-1 start in October, Pro Football Weekly splashed the powerful end on its cover and proclaimed him, "The Newest Monster of the Midway." Middle linebacker Brian Urlacher, Peppers' highly decorated teammate, called him the best defensive player in the NFL.

He even pleased at least one tough critic.

"Julius Peppers impresses me as much as anyone," Jones says. "He has it all."

 

i meant when he was a panther

 

also answer the second question please

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

julius peppers accepting his 2013 defensive player of the year award just like predatorpeppers predicted:

 

[CRA]

Are you looking at all time in the league or solely time with the Panthers?

Anytime we're talking about a 'best Panther' question, i exclude anything done outside of this team.

He had 6 10+ sack seasons while in Carolina.....and in of those padded it with INTs, FFs etc.

89 hit double digit TDs once. 89 was always more of a yardage and tone setter who made timely plays.

Pep wins the stat sheet battle in Carolina over 89. Stats are what drives most discussions when players are discussed outside of fanbases.

[CatMan72]

I think Peppers at his best was our best all time... we just didn't get his best very often.

When Peppers was on he could totally take over a game.

Sent from my SM-N900V using CarolinaHuddle mobile app