TheCasillas

I shared a tweet earlier in the thread showing data that is the opposite of this statement.

less than 17 points per game...... less than 200 yards passsing..... and less than 50% completion percetnage... that was our offense with subaverage QB play. Nothing needs to be made up.... its right there in the numbers.

wouldnt his performance here have us with a winning record?

I dont understand how he has slipped.... he has thrown 11 TDs to 2 INTs over the last 8 games with a 89 QBR and over 65% completion percentage. McDaniels is destroying yet another franchise with his system. I didnt think McD would be bad again... thats a different topic. Do you have examples that I could review of Carr slipping? Are we sure it's not the system?

Carr could be our Tom Brady (Bucs) or Matt Stafford (Rams)....

Just helping you :) https://www.yardbarker.com/nfl/articles/derek_carr_somehow_owns_several_clutch_records/s1_16892_37619578#:~:text=The NFL on CBS Twitter,(23) in the NFL.

something tells me this doesnt track.... (hint: 2022 off-season)

I can agree with this thinking. I wouldn’t call him a retread though, because no one has given up on Carr, maybe they have given up on the franchise. He is a great player stuck in a poo situation. Put him on another team in the NFC South and they are #1 in the division.

Age? 31 for a QB is not old, haha. I have no idea a what he would cost, but I wouldnt go higher than a couple of 3rds.

This roster is a plug and play QB away from competing. Adding Carr for a couple of mid rounders and then beefing up the roster with the rest of the picks is a pretty appetizing scenario. raiders would be dumb to trade him, but him in black and blue and even more young studs around him… that sounds like an intriguing scenario.

How is he a “project?”

The jets elevated Mike White last week for a reason… now that he is healthy, I think Wilson is on a short leash.

Derek Carr isn’t a failed project…. He is a solid qb stuck playing for a poo franchise

I feel for the guy. That locker room has given up.

Carson wentz and baker mayfield went to the playoffs their second and third seasons…. They must have been great picks for those two franchises!

I’d agree if CMC was the lead back for the niners…. But Mitchel got more carries and snaps than CMC last night…..

Is CMC the power back for the niners now?

yea those broncos vs raiders games are going to be barn burners, oh! and the rams vs raiders... let's not forget the raiders vs steelers. Games of the year material right there..

In all honesty, my opinion on the upcoming QB class... is not close to complete. I am trying to get hyped about the options and each one has glaring weaknesses. I am not even trying to find the perfect QB, just someone who could compete. I think at this point im down to Richardson and Young. I think bowl season is going to create the clearest picture.

So then you understand his short comings. Again, he is an elite talent, just needs to figure out how to be a pro QB.

As I shared before, Ive moved on from Levis. After week 5 , it was evident. So we can stop with that, haha.

you are forgetting the main issue... Fields struggles to read the field and throw the ball. He is similiar to Darnold on reading the field. However, he can bail himself out with his feet. I am not sure if you are able to watch every play from the Bears games... but Fields struggles to get the ball out quick and tends to hold onto it. It is a big issue with him. The stats are solid but the on field play would be horrendous if he wasnt running as well as he is. This isnt hate on the guy.... its just that he cant see the field.

a few posts ago you said they were only one WR and a olineman away from being a top offense... I am confused now.... The one thing Im certain about is that Fields is just not a good passer.... yet.

he is averaging under 6 yards per throw, and less than 160 yards per game.... he has thrown 12 TDs to 7 INTs.... Thats pretty bad... slap that on any other QB... are you goign to defend those numbers?

beat me to it.