fanpanther

Giving up a few 1st round pics for a qb who has been in the bottom ten of qbr for his first 3 years in the league seems like something this gm would do lol. Garndner minshew is rated higher than fields currently i just dont see why people think fields is awesome.

Dont know who the other guy is but I created this account a few months back after reading posts for a while and finally deciding to join. As for justin fields he has had 2 good games this year and only one above 300 with a really good group around him. 2 years before that below average. I dont see bringing him into a worse team by far and expecting him to increase the play of anyone around him. I could be wrong and perhaps someone trades for him and he does amazing things but personally i would rather risk any rookie or see if young can do anyrhing at all next year over trading anymore draft capital

He doesnt appear to be giving his best effort perhaps bc he has lost faith in young or perhaps he is terrible also but he did run 4.46 at nfl combine

Crazy to think if they had let young sit on the bench all year dalton could have easily had panthers in contention for nfc south and playoffs . People would be talking about reich takin the panthers to the playoffs and the resergence of dalton possibly.. instead the coaches would do better with no qb running wildcat then to have young on the field total coach killer

Justin fields somehow still gets love the dude is terrible the bears fans are happy to get rid of him trading for him is right up the alley of another dumb thing for tepper to do. Panthers would be better rolling with any rookie qb then a proven loser in fields. I dont understand how people still think he is good what has he done for the bears?

I hope some team would throw the panthers a draft pic for him in the offseason so we can see what he looks like on another team.

Bryce was 13 of 39 with 137yards and 2 turnovers I am pretty sure that is by far the worse performance of the week for the league. That should be a new award worse qb in the nfc and afc weekly. Pretty sure young would have alot of those.

If thielan had a decent qb he could be leadin thr nfl in several categories with bryce young throwing he is still gonna make the probowl most likely in nfc and is top 10 in yards and catches

Young has been so terrible the fact that he is throwing deep even though his throws have been incredibly inaccurate is a positive lol

Watching this game he has time he has open receivers he is just missing throws holdin ball too long and making terrible reads throwing to the covered instead of uncovered people. Even the young defenders have to admit he is looking terrible.

Yeah no clue how this didn't immediately stand out too the panthers front office as a huge red flag along with the rest of the red flags.

I actually am less amazed by the deserved hate he is getting and more amazed by the people blindly defending him blaming everyone and everything else but him. I could at least understand all the Cam defenders towards the end b/c he had done so much for the Panthers but Young has done nothing and has only been a Panther for a short while so really dont understand the defenders

I saw a comment from an alabama fan that watched him play in college talk about how terrible his deep ball was in college. He said his deep ball accuracy was atrocious I cant remember the stat he said and not even sure it was true but it was something like he completed only 10% of his deep throws in college. With all that said not sure how the 1st overall grade got put on Young.

Mac jones has a 6 point better qbr and had a 300 yard game with some close to 300s been terrible but would still give him the edge. Zach Wilson is a point behind young in qbr they seem really similiar across the board at the moment ..so yep Young has been historically bad I heard some announcer say he has the lowest ypa in modern nfl history.

Still waiting on Bryce to have even one of these games though sadly hope it happens soon though.

Just looking at all the teams in the nfl pretty much every single qb in the entire nfl is playing better than Bryce Young. Late round qbs undrafted qbs backup qbs pretty much every single QB is playing better with the exception being the Jets QBs who are playing pretty similiarly. That says alot. I hate to go back to stroud but his 3rd round rookie wr tank dell goes down and he takes another no name backup wr and gives him almost 200 yards in a game. Great QBs make the oline the wr the rb the entire team better right now Bryce is making the entire team worse. Hopefully it just starts clicking but he really needed a year to sit and learn if he ever does take the leap forward to being a good nfl qb.

All Bryce needs is for every other player on the team to be all pro at their positions and he will be at least an average qb ......seriously hope he plays better but its not looking good saw another article comparing his and daltons in depth metrics and it wasnt pretty either. This is the link to that one. https://www.sportsinfosolutions.com/2023/11/08/bryce-young-was-a-college-legend-but-hes-not-a-good-fit-for-the-pros/

No one can win instantly with this team with Young at QB. If Tepper wanted instant wins he should have went with a Vet QB or drafted a better rookie QB. Not sure Reich was the answer but the staff assembled on paper seemed amazing and to just fire him after 11 games with what he had to work with really sends a terrible message to possible candidates.

Not sure its Reichs fault that Young has been a terrible QB and the GM and owner made a terrible trade and draft choice. With all that being said if suddenly Young passes for 300 yards a game and we putting up 21 or more points weekly I will be proven wrong which I hope I am.

This is one thing I dont understand everyone that is defending Young always act like the Texans are a team of probowlers. Their Oline is playing better but how much of that is Stroud causing defenses to worry about the pass and his escapability. Below is the Oline rankings midseason vs start of the year. How much of the drop or increase is from the QB playing quicker and better its hard to really know. WR they have no one of note but Stroud seems to also have elevated their play. Everyone hates on Theilen but he is 4th in the nfl in receptions and 15th in yardage with young basically throwing a checkdown every play. Imagine if he had a different QB. I hope Young plays better but watching him play reminds me of the Jimmy Clausen QB days. 12. Houston Texans (Preseason Rank: 23) 27. Carolina Panthers (Preseason Rank: 17)

He has made sports center a lot lately though.....although they have been pick six the other way.

Bryce has the lowest QBR in the entire league and that is saying alot considering so many injuries to starting QBs and rookie qbs playing. I would like to see Dalton play a game or two more just to see if its a huge upgrade then we know it really is Bryce holding the entire offense back. Its really hard to gage if Reich is a good coach or not b/c Young seems so limited physically that it seems they have to scale back the playbook a ton. I have no clue how the scouts did not notice his total lack of velocity.

the offense actually looked worse under brown....if thats his fault or youngs is debatable. the yards per game, the points scored offensively ...pretty much every category got worse with brown as play caller.

Its hard to know if the current coaching staff is good or not. Its only a few games into the first year. Young seems extremely limited and hopefully not a bust but trending that way. Assuming the GM decided to trade the 6th overall the 2024 1st overall a top 10 wr, several 2nds and 3rds for the number 1 overall that was far from a sure fire pic we need a new GM if the coach was on board with that we need a new coach also. Hindsite is 5050 but its not looking good at all with no light at end of tunnel. They will roll at least one more year with young no matter what. this is a really good article kinda summing up all that is trending wrong with young https://www.sportsinfosolutions.com/2023/11/08/bryce-young-was-a-college-legend-but-hes-not-a-good-fit-for-the-pros/