CanadianCat

If this was a year from now and we had already addressed the defense then I could see the reasoning for this. But thats not this year. Also, he has been the best player on the team the last 10 years. Lets respect that he wants to retire here..

Paywall..

I mean, it was pretty funny that they did that.. Then we all learned that Tepper cannot take a joke (or people wearing hats). I fully support people trolling billionaires.

I mean the point was exactly that, that its insinuated that the Tepper's meddled in the draft process. Thus forced the pick to be Young. My point is Young was the best graded player that draft year.

Bryce Young was the consensus #1 pick that year.. Anything else is revisionist history. How some of you have such short memories...

All I hear in this is you dont have enough confidence to change careers.. Like I posted, if you know better than the current scouts, change jobs and make a bag. Im sure you could teach Dan Morgan a thing or two about linebacker play.

Here you go, I did the research for you. Go earn yourself $500,00+ just submit your resume. Entry-Level Scouts: Typically, entry-level NFL scouts can earn between $20,000 to $95,000 per year. These positions are usually reserved for scouting assistants or regional scouts who are just starting out. Mid-Level Scouts: With a few years of experience, scouts can earn between $95,000 to $275,000 per year. These scouts may have more responsibilities, such as covering specific regions or handling advanced football analytics. Top-Level Scouts or Directors of Scouting: Experienced scouts in senior positions can make anywhere from $275,000 to $500,000+ annually. Directors of scouting or player personnel have higher salaries, sometimes approaching seven figures.

Yeah, ok... So if you are so brilliant then why don't you show your scouting reports to teams and get an actual NFL job.. SMH I get so tired of people saying they are smarter than people who hold actual jobs in this industry but just choose to be a small team market internet scout. Come on dude. Also I get how you can say that you would have drafted another player over someone like Brooks. Sure thats a simple argument that one can make without being employed. But your missing all the conversations that lead to that being the pick and why. Picking players in a bubble is not the same as picking it on a team where you have differing scouting reports and feed back from different coaches about how they could be used vs other players with similar grades and those other players could be used. Then put on top of all of that what the team strategy is for the season. Picking players in a bubble is not the same as picking it on a team.

Honestly I've been unexcited about Walker. Im not usually a fan of 'hybrid' players. They rarely workout (all respect to TD) But after watching Luke talk about him... Im all in on him being the pick

I mean I would go if I got an invite... it would be a cool experience, one that almost no one gets. You just need to temper your expectations.

I mean drafting at the best of times is a crap shoot. The entire NFL is not good at it (AKA Brock Purdy). Also we (the Huddle collective) always think we know better. When we drafted "Mrs Rhules" pick, AKA Chuba, the entire collective here thought it was a terrible pick.

I dont know why so many people are worried about this signing. There is literally no risk to the team on this. It a 'throw s#it at the wall and see what sticks" kinda move. Maybe he becomes a great redzone option? Maybe he gets cut before training camp? Shake the tree and see what falls out.

Parity is a thing in the NFL I dont think its shocking to see bad teams become good when you plug in a few key players and decent coaching. But sustained success is harder to achieve. Houston made a big jump year 1 with CJ and came crashing back down this past year.

Which ones?

Unless its a complete disaster this coming year, like coaching incompetence, I think Dave and and Dan get a 3rd year together. I suspect that Tepper is going to be overly patient with the staff. That said, while I can see us only winning 6-9 games this year I see those games being played very differently this year. Last year was us getting beat up on. I think this year we play competitive ball and see another year of growth in our young players like Young, XL, Sanders I dont expect playoffs this year, but I expect to see major steps forward on both sides of the ball.

that was weak...

What I would love to see... Trade back to the early teens for an additional 3rd and draft the best remaining DL. Of the guys we are looking at (Walker, Campbell, Stewart, Williams or Green) 1 or 2 of those will be available. Easy.

I still support the discussion to move on from TB5. Teddy was always planned to be the bridge QB. I dont think he ever could have amounted to much, and I think that is backed up by the fact that he went on to do nothing after we moved on from him. You can make a better argument that we made the right decision trade for Darnold OR Baker and the bad decision was to move on from either one of them.

Listen, I dont know anything about these players and I dont follow CFB at all.. but if he was never even questioned by the police then what are we talking about here?

I agree changing QB's and coaches every year will never result in success. That said.. Teddy was named "Teddy check down" for a reason.. Could we given him a better chance? Yes, but I dont think it was a bad decision to move on. Darnold: I supported trading what we did for a potential Franchise QB. The team failed him. The right coach in place and we would be miles a head of where we are today. Baker: I supported (and always will) taking a shot at a QB. The team failed him. We had 2 maybe 3 potential Franchise QB's on the roster but we didnt have a good team around them or a plan. Both have gone on to become a Franchise QB for other teams while we continued to rebuild. That said Young came into his own this last year. I anticipate a big step this year.

The biggest take away, and Im surprised that no one mentioned it is where they asked Tilis if the reason for the structure of the deals being mostly 2 year deals is because of BY potential contract and he said, "... we didnt think too much about Bryce and where he is, thats still TBD."

I would agree but Carolina is not often the team used for 'click bait'

I agree. I would be happy for the player but upset about the trade. We are NOT 1 player away.. we cannot afford this trade.

Panthers trade 8, 57, 74, 2026 2RD for Giants #3 overall and draft Abdul Carter. Thoughts?