poundaway

24 minutes ago, PanthersGOATFan336 said:

I get it you like Bryce but he doesn't seperate himself enough to say he's going to be a top 5 qb from stroud who has less concerns..

Yes.  Yes he does.

And the analysis shows that bigger QBs get hurt more dude.  Our experience has show that.

Bryce is clearly more elusive in the pocket and is FAR superior under pressure.

31 minutes ago, stan786 said:

How long does Bryce need to go uninjured for people to not say I told you so if he gets hurt? A season? Two? Or are you gonna be holding it in the chamber until it happens?

Its a waste of time.  They say the same thing over and over. 

Let me just say, if we take Stroud and HE gets hurt and Bryce doesn't,  there will be shlt storm too because the reason we took Stroud over Bryce's superior play was because of "durability" concerns, even though the analysis and our history clearly show that the bigger QB gets hurt more. 

I'm willing to bet Stroud gets hurt before Bryce simply because he is less slippery in the pocket.   

46 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

You are probably right, but why not just say it? Also why bring in AR and Stroud for visits? It seems they are fairly confident it’s Young but are still doing some research.

Who knows.  I'm not convinced Person's source knows much.

14 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

Are the trade down rumors just bull crap right now? Sounds like they are pretty locked in with their choice.

Shouldn't they be locked in?   They have years of tape, the pro-days and combine.  They've met these players, talked to their coaches and know their game inside and out.

The playbook has been made.    They could have written it for 3 potential QBs, but I doubt it.   

If the OP is even remotely true, they won't consider a trade at all, no matter how much they offer.   There's no scenario where Richardson or Stroud are possibles.  As if they really believe that Young could be something special.  Meanwhile Houston is probably taking Anderson.

Stroud's mom has a lot of accounts on here.

1 minute ago, CPF4LIFE said:

This is just a wild guess,  you dont know that all. Lol 

He was pretty quiet during Rhule's years.

So I was fully expecting Ryan Day to say something somewhere publicly after this came out to disavow the statement that Stroud isn't easy to coach.  It's in Ohio States best interest to have the #1 overall come from their team after all and Day's worked with Stroud.

Has anybody heard Day, or the OC or QB coach say something in response? 

7 minutes ago, KSpan said:

I'm not saying he's lying or anything but what else is he really going to say? Luke is not going to talk bad about anyone.

If Luke truly thought Young was a mistake, he'd say nothing.

Luke may be a Panthers puppet just saying whatever they tell him to, but I doubt it.

10 minutes ago, Hoenheim said:

 

I'm impressed what Fit has done picking up WRs in free agency. We've got a pretty diverse group with Theielen, Chark, TMJ, Byrd, and Shi Smith 

 

and Shenault.

5 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

I can already see it next year if/when he gets hurt the debate will still be about his size and if that contributed to it.   

or maybe he plays all 17 games and Stroud gets hurt

6 minutes ago, OldhamA said:

You're on a fan message board, my dude. Have some self awareness. 

All in good fun buddy.

"I know football better than Luke, Smitty, the entire Panthers staff and everyone who has Young at the top of his board."

Just now, ncfan said:

But we can have “Horn And Darnold”

 

I love Horn.  But this quote still Haunts me.

And now the niners are going forward with Mr. Irrelevant and Darnold with talk of trading away Lance.

https://theathletic.com/4362274/2023/03/30/trey-lance-trade-49ers-mailbag/

23 minutes ago, stan786 said:

 

Now that is funny.

Their D is definitely going to be better.

Just now, Jackie Lee said:

 

This.

Just now, PanthersGOATFan336 said:

Stop spitting nonsense..

https://mobile.twitter.com/CraigStock8675/status/1638108163466485760

Now show those number under pressure.  His numbers drop off a cliff.

The heavier the QB, the more he gets injured.

2 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

now ask yourself why arent short guys allowed to play qb?

Bias.

15 minutes ago, PanthersGOATFan336 said:

 

 

The Stroud Boys are going to whine an complain all the way to the draft.

The S2 is not the deciding factor.  The tape is.  Stroud has a 40% completion rate under pressure and is mostly a statue in the pocket. 

If these guys were just taller, they never would have gotten hurt.

4 minutes ago, Jon Snow said:

Especially when CMC finished 2 seasons on IR. 

Yeah, especially since CMC got hurt, AFTER he bulked up.

2 hours ago, mrcompletely11 said:

theres been like 2 in modern era under 6ft.  Murray being the most recent and he hasnt completed a full season yet.

 

Now ask yourself why have there only been 2 qbs under 6ft to play qb in the modern era if size doesnt matter?

Easy.  Bias.  Its rampant on here. The size queens are like Rhule and his longer arm shlt.

Now you ask yourself, why haven't the smallest QBs, whatever size they were, getting hurt more?  Name some examples of the 6 ft QB who got hurt because he was 6 foot.