frankw

You know full well those are dubious comparisons at best because none of the QB's you mentioned are also the smallest QB in the league. Bryce Young is like it or not working from a disadvantage in just about every facet on an NFL field and that is why we need things to go perfect for him in order for him to have a productive day let alone for him to look like a top 10 QB. Some people just don't want to face the truth. Well you can only run from it for so long. Good luck with that.

Most of the comments I've seen have been very scathingly critical of Canales in game management and decisions. Evero and multiple key defenders have gotten a ton of smoke too. As far as Bryce goes I think it depends on the viewer. Some people were all about giving him credit for game winning drives even when he basically did little or nothing but still received the credit. Now the same people want to cry foul when Bryce is expected to as a third year QB and a first overall pick not lose to a rookie 2nd round pick 8 games into his career. Well I'm sorry it just doesn't work that way. He's the face of the franchise. He's the third highest paid player on the team this year. The team goes as the QB goes. Aside from the late sack he was kept relatively clean throughout the bulk of the game even with the injuries we've had along the OL. Shough on the other hand was harassed throughout the game and he still completed passes into tight windows throughout the game. Bryce on the other hand while he is receiving a positive grade for his scrambling saw fit to bail on the pocket throughout the game. Some of those were justified others were not and resulted in missed opportunities. Then there is the elephant in the room that even Dave Canales himself even uttered the quiet part out loud about. That is the fact that in short yardage situations we cannot under any circumstances use our #1 pick on a QB sneak. Which let's just keep it 100 here. If this were any other team everyone here including the loudest Bryce defenders would be laughing their asses off. All of this encompasses a singular conclusion that no matter how much people may like Bryce Young the person ultimately he does not appear to be a QB that we can compete for and win in the playoffs with. It isn't hating or any other ridiculous label to acknowledge this reality. It's just life.

The Panthers never should have been in position for this to matter. When we went up 17-10 the Saints actually fumbled on their next drive and a good team actually trying to win their division and lock up a playoff spot would have recovered that fumble and gone on to make the score 24-10. This was a sloppy game from a team known for just that in situations where the pressure is on. And Dave Canales himself basically said the bye week was a factor and that to me is as good of an indicator we should need that we need to prioritize any and all possible head coaching candidate upgrades in the offseason.

Bryce was sacked one time and that didn't happen until what late in the 4th quarter? Shough was throwing into tight windows under duress all through the first half my man. The proof is in the pudding.

He. Has. The. Highest. Paid. OL. In. The. Entire. League. Nobody is absolving Icky for getting penalized. But Icky is not the face of the franchise. Icky is not currently the third highest paid player on the team. Icky did not get outplayed by Tyler Shough who was sacked 5 times and consistently harassed by our DL. We aren't going to agree. It's fine. Good day sir!

Dumping on Icky to cover for our #1 pick being outplayed by a rookie is such embarrassing foolishness.

Wilks is a good man but he is not a very good coach. It happens. Time to move on from this once and for all.

The fat lady has sung. Can't get swept by the Saints and a rookie QB and still consider yourself a contender of any kind.

Bryce was sacked once. Shough was sacked 5 times. We beat him up all throughout the first half. His best RB was out. He still had the better performance. Some of you have standards for everyone but Bryce Young and it's just sad.

When Bryce looks good we have weapons. When Bryce gets outplayed by a rookie 8 games into his career suddenly we have nobody. I love this place.

Well at least the Hornets won. 25 points for Miller 29 points for Knueppel.

It's for the best this team doesn't get a playoff spot anyways. Being swept by the Saints indicates we would just suffer another embarrassment.

And the end result will be the same as it has been with now two different coaching staffs.

Bryce to his credit did not play anywhere near as bad as he had in previous outings against the Saints. He had some good moments. But that's a testament to just how horrible he has played at times that when he plays mid we see it as a monumental achievement. Ultimately when you watch all four quarters of this loss you will see that even though Bryce had some success the offense is still being held back by him. We run this offense to his strengths to a fault and everything has to go perfect for him to have success. The TD throw to Coker was a great play between him and Jalen but even with that it was an example of a defender getting caught flat footed. Bryce was in no way shape or form throwing lasers into tight or contested windows like Shough was and Shough was under duress for much of the first half and even the third quarter while Bryce was largely kept clean. It's funny you mention Parcells. Parcells himself accurately summarized what Bryce Young would need to be and do in the NFL in order to justify going #1 with his glaring physical limitations. "He better walk on water". We've seen terrible from Bryce Young. We've seen really good. We've seen mid. None of those versions of Bryce Young will ever get this team to competing in and winning playoff games. Even when he has looked really good it's been sandwiched between games like the 49ers loss. Bryce has graduated from being abysmal. He's now a so so servicable starter in ideal conditions. But that's not what we traded the farm for. In that regard it's time to keep looking. Nothing personal against him nothing biased just plain old fashioned acknowledgement of reality and the situation as it stands. And to be clear Bryce is not the only part of this roster we need to be taking a long hard look at. There are guys some of whom are making a boatload of money who need to be consistent or else too. And our head coach needs to call a better game in crucial moments and stop getting outcoached or we need to weigh all possible options in the offseason. I said all along this game would be a watershed moment for this roster this staff and this team with finally breaking a curse of 8 years of losing at stake. There are many difficult truths we need to be facing after this loss. And no matter how uncomfortable it may be each and every one of those truths must be faced head on. Beginning with the most consequential position on the football field.

Oh god I can hear it.

Not being able to run a QB sneak after trading the farm for a QB is something we would be laughing our asses off at every chance we got if this were any other team.

Dave Canales deserves all the smoke.

QB's overwhelmingly win games when it matters most and that is what Shough did in both games while Bryce floundered. I understand you've effortlessly slipped back into your contrarian know it all shtick but reality is reality. And no you don't need to quote me any further.

People have been saying for awhile now that Jaycee Horn (while talented and capable of flashing great play from time to time) still isn't worth top 3 corner money because he is too inconsistent. Still doesn't change the fact that a rookie QB 8 games into his career outplayed and swept our 3rd year QB 43 games into his career. And Dave Canales continues to get outcoached. Hard truths all around.

Good lord we should have just kneeled it that was insult to injury.

Defense is 28 out of 32 in salary cap allocation for the year. Bryce Young has the highest paid OL in the league.

QB QB QB QB QB QB QB QB QB QB QB QB Somehow the Saints have a better QB than us. We're going nowhere until that changes.

Franchise QB over everything else. You can always hire another DC. You can't consistently overcome your #1 pick being outplayed and swept by a guy the league resoundingly clowned them for drafting. He ain't the guy. It is what it is.

As much as Evero is a problem. The fact that Shough has outplayed our #1 pick in both games is an even bigger problem. I would argue it is the problem and nothing will change until we shore up this QB room.

Salt - wound.