Catsfan69

In which case he didn't have the longevity. Lol and no. At no time was he an elite arm. He has been inaccurate AF since day 1. Plenty of games he lost in crunch time due to blowing throws. I don't get why you guys can't be honest about him. Makes no sense the infatuation.

Because I am sick and tired of Cam fans that try to elevate him to some position he's not. Cam people brought up the HOF. The people on this board are like the guys that gas up fat chicks online calling them beautiful and sexy. That's why. He's a great Football player not a diety.

Maybe. I just think when it comes down to Championship or no Championship you need a QB that can win with his arm and make great throws in crunch time. Russ is Duel threat weighted towards throwing. Mahomes is also Weighted towards throwing. Young again duel threat weighted towards throwing. I can't remember a QB winning a Superbowl who was weighted towards running. Of course I could be mistaken.

I wouldn't put Rhule in Jimmy's category in College or the NFL.

Hate it for him. Love it for the tank.

I think Russ is heads and shoulders better than Cam. That list isn't in order just who popped into my head when I was at a Red Light. There have been many days I wished we had waited a year and took Russ

What are you talking about? Rivers was a much better QB than Cam. It's the truth. Why are you so biased towards Cam?

There's nobody on that list that you'd take Cam over. Not if you're honest. Especially not the elites. He's just not in their class.

When healthy Cmac is one of the deadliest threats in the NFL running the ball. He's a threat to score every single rush.

Compare him to his peers. He's way worse than Brady Rogers Breese Roethlisberger Rivers Manning those guys are all eons better than him. Then Wilson Palmer Carr Stafford Eli Ryan Probably Luck were all better than him. I mean during his run he just wasn't that good compared to the other QBs in the league. Not HOF material.

Jake or Cam

He's elite inside the 10

How did he revolutionize the game exactly? He can't throw. He never has been a passer. QBs are judged on passing the ball and he has always been slightly above average to below average. I don't care that he was a glorified RB as far as the Hall goes. He's a great Football player for us. Ring of honor absolutely. But even in his MVP season he wasn't the best QB. You can't put someone in the hall that wasn't the best at his position for at least one single year in their career.

Just going to the playoffs isn't good enough

I don't know who he bribed.

He's not a HOF QB. Nowhere close to being a good enough passer plus zero rings.

Which is what I've been saying all year. Get a new staff. Keep Sam. Keep Cam for Redzone Draft the best OL we can. Then if it fails we are sitting pretty to draft in 23.

I'm telling you making him our Taysom Hill is the smart play. It's what he still excels at. Use him inside the Redzone for 2mil a year.

It's exactly what he should do. What I've said since he signed. Be our Redzone Taysom Hill. I'd sign him for 2mil next year to be Taysom Hill. That's what he is best at.

This is the problem. Sam had the same obstacles to overcome but everything was his fault. Now that Cam has the same problems it's not his fault. Call it even.

This is correct

Damn underthrown was that Kyle Allen?

Why are you knighting for Cam?

Just like with Sam

I mean Cam isn’t a world beater either. He's Taysom Hill at this point.