Catsfan69

He's scrambled once. Scrambling good Designed runs bad

He's mobile. It just proves running as a QB will never be a long-term solution to winning in the NFL. You have to be able to distribute the ball. He literally just said that in his post-game interview.

You talking about Allen? That's why he lost. He just said he didn't play QB well enough today to win.

I never considered it one in the same. I've always distinguished mobile from dual threat from running qbs

Throwing will always be the most important trait. The further down the line your QBs arm is the further from the Superbowl you get. I've said it a million times I'll take tons of QBs over Cam that played in the league while he did if we are judging their prime vs his. Russ Breese Ben Brady Payton Elway Allen Burrow Rivers Watson Luck Stafford Mahomes do I need to keep going?

He's mobile because he has an elite arm. Mobile > dual threat

You don't know how to read. Was Staubach mobile Young Mahomes Yes. But it was in top of elite arms. They won because of their arms not their legs

The QBs I seek Staubach Russ Big Ben Manning Warren Moon Fouts Young Montana And on and on and on would all still be franchise guys today. I'll take prime Russ Moon lamar and Mahomes over Cam any day of the week. The number one measurement of a QB is arm and passing ability. Plain and simple. Allen can throw Cousins can throw Russ traditionally can throw Brady can throw Lamar can throw Rogers can throw Herbert Burrows can throw. I want a guy that can dice you up. Not some jag that can kinda get it in the vicinity. Fields is more vicinity than surgical

I absolutely do. You however confuse Techmo Bowl with real life.

No it's about ability to win only with your arm. And run when only necessary.

What that POS Brady just did with no time left shows you that a surgical arm beats incredible legs every single time. You just can't drive the field otherwise.

These Tampa WRs are dropping everything

Mobile QBs do. Dual threat don't I can list tons of mobile qbs in history that have won. Mobile QB is where the sweet spot is.

Jordan and kobe weren't point guards. Their job is akin to recivers.

If he runs for 170 and only passes for 170 yes that's bad. If he runs for 170 and only passes for 209 that's bad. Long term success would be throw for 330 and run for 30.

If rushing yards are half your production as a QB you'll never win a Superbowl. The goal is to find a Championship caliber QB. Not a highlight reel that looks good on Madden.

I explained it to you. Running is the icing not the cake. Running was a fraction of the game of Steve Young, Russell Wilson, Patrick Mahomes, Roger Staubach. You can't win a Superbowl if half your game is your ability to run. You aren't Running 80 yards in less than 2 minutes with 1 timeout. You have to be able to distribute the football. I bet you prefer Allen Iverson over Magic and Stockton.

How many passing yards?

Mahomes as a passer is light years better than Cam ever was. Cam was an above average to good passer. But nowhere close to being elite. Running and passing combined he was the 10th to 12th best QB in the league. And if you can play hypothetical out of every QB in the NFL during his career there's probably at least 20 I would have traded him for straight up. Maybe 30.

It's odd that you are in love with a guy who has never and will.never play for us. Honestly I hope he fails. It's one less team to worry about in the NFC

I wanted Slater but when our turn came up I thought it would be Fields. Horn wasn't on my radar with that pick

Yes Cam is better than both of them. But that didn't make Cam an elite QB. He was good but we definitely need to set the bar higher than that. We need a Mahomes, Rodgers, Brady level passer. I don't care if the guy is a statue as long as he can deal.

Why are you so enamored with runs by a QB?

Well you can't change the personnel. You can only change the scheme so much. Same on offense.

Fields is an average passer. You can't win the Superbowl with an average passer. Running as a QB is a vastly overrated trait. Especially on The Huddle