Jump to content

Catsfan69

HUDDLER
  • Posts

    7,005
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Catsfan69

  1. The Golden Calf of Bristol below average QB great Football player. His ego got in his own way.
  2. Lol I didn't say I'd trade for Joe. Just that I had forgotten about him as a peer at all.
  3. Not as a football player. As a QB. A QB like a point guard is supposed to be a Distributor of the ball. Passing is the number one skill a QB should be judged on. Rushing, Rushing TDs is just the icing not the cake.
  4. Doesn't Eli have 2 Superbowl MVPs with his Rings? Big Ben is way better than Cam and INEC. Rivers much better passer.
  5. You're entitled to your opinion. But yes I would have taken them over Cam. Young guys that aren't exactly his peers I'm taking Mahomes and a cleared of wrongdoing Watson over Cam at any point in his career as well. And when you are willing to trade him for Non Hall guys like Rivers and Eli then he's not HOF.
  6. Yes compared to all the QBs I listed he can't throw. He was a very good QB for us. How exactly did I defend a racist. Be specific.
  7. Off the top of my head cause I am driving I might not get to 8. Brady Big Ben Rivers Breese Wilson rogers Eli Pre Inury Payton
  8. During his run with us I probably would have traded him instantly for probably 8 to 12 other QBs. Not just one or two.
  9. What's hard about talk to text? Plus I never said he was lousy. I said he's not a HOFr. Big difference there.
  10. Well I think you don't play it even. You should change your screen name to Clete.
  11. So you wouldn't trade Cam for say 2007 Tom Brady? Just straight up no picks no cap issues?
  12. Lol what part of he was done physically and didn't win the game don't you get?
  13. He did when he was younger. That game was rigged and you know it
  14. We got jobbed plain and simple. Payton was done after his neck injury
  15. Answer this healthy Cam in May of 2016. NE calls and says Brady for Cam straight up. Do you pull the trigger? How about GB and Rogers?
  16. No I'm saying you don't trade a hofr for an equal commodity. See if I was GB for example there is nobody I'd trade Rogers for. Same for Brady Payton and maybe Breese. I'm not trading those guys at all. Big Ben I'm only considering a trade for Brady or Rogers. With Cam there's a lot of guys you insta trade for. BTW you didn't answer the question.
  17. I'll make this simple for you. All names in their prime would you trade Cam for straight up in his prime. Brady PAYTON Breese Rivers Stafford Wilson Roethlisberger Eli Ryan Rogers Carr If you can name more than two you'd trade him for then no he's not HOF.
  18. He was an above average QB and great Football player. Those aren't the same things. When he was healthy he was the 10th or 12th best QB in the league which makes him not elite There are tons of guys I would have traded him for if life was like a video game. Elite QBs you aren't willing to trade for anyone.
  19. He just stole the TDs from them. They'd get us inside the 3 then he'd keep the ball.
  20. Some of that's true. But what's also true is we drafted duds like KB and Funches because of catch radius because Cam couldn't consistently put the ball on the money.
×
×
  • Create New...