mrcompletely11

and your best response was a 10 year old article talking about qbs from a different era, like I said dont stop being you as that was funny as hell

holy poo holy fuging poo lololololololololololololol Dont ever stop being you dude

no dude you cherry picked 3 cases involving HOF qbs to somehow justify your point that Baker is good despite being kicked to the curb and all three cases are vastly different then what we are talking about. How about this, take out your extreme cases and solve the problem again. How many qbs are dropped from their team go on to have great careers?

Because you are comparing Mayfield to HOF qbs dude. Jesus h christ

oof https://theathletic.com/3367945/2022/07/06/mayfield-panthers-browns-trade-facts/ What do the stats say about Mayfield’s performance? It’s been more meh and blah than good in terms of a few overarching metrics. Mayfield’s Estimated Points Added per dropback (via TruMedia) ranks 27th among qualified quarterbacks from the past four years at 0.03 (43 qualified quarterbacks). During the last four individual seasons, Mayfield’s best single season in EPA per dropback (via TruMedia) was in 2020. His 0.12 EPA ranked 39th among all individual quarterback seasons (131 QB seasons) from 2018-2021. Mayfield’s other three seasons: 2018: 0.07 (65th) 2019: -0.01 (95th) 2021: -0.05 (107th) In passer rating terms, Mayfield’s 88.3 mark ranks 33rd among the 43 qualified passers. Of the individual seasons in the span, Mayfield’s best passer rating came in 2020 at 96.9 (51st) among 131 QB seasons. Mayfield’s other three seasons: 2018: 94.3 (63rd) 2019: 79.0 (119th) 2021: 83.5 (109th)

With Geno smith and drew lock on the roster. With a coaching staff with multiple playoff runs.....hmmmmmmmm

so you admit it was a stupid thing to post, thanks

brees and manning were hurt the pats wanted brady back and that is funny as hell you are comparing 3 HOF qbs to mayfield, any port in a storm I guess

why would you remove that trade? It didnt happen?

one bad year? 6-12-6-6 hmmmmmmmm

yep, like I said getting clowned

spoiler alert: Hes not

clown show franchise and now everyone is teeing off on us

bingo

Which is my argument all along, it shouldnt have gotten to this point where we are fuging trading for Baker even after the Darnold and teddy disasters. It was a fuged plan from the jump and keeps getting fuged as we go forward.

6-12-6-6 Yearly wins for baker. Thats bearable to you?

Like I said, this is worst case scenario, we are going to extend this jackass based on average play Seems like just yesterday Fitt was bragging about scouting wilson, drafting him and then turning him loose into a franchise qb.

fair enough 6-12-6-6 he is a below .500 qb with a stacked roster

We got marginally better compared to sam fuging darnold however its in the short term. This doesnt do jack poo in regards to our long term goal and team building. So what the fuging point is having Baker on a one year deal if we are going to let him walk? This doesnt make sense but then again I am arguing with a dude that defend signing teddy and trading for Darnold. Baker is not a franchise qb and there are now 4 years worth of data to prove it.

but but but we got better or something

I did 2 miles and underestimated the heat, hence my return oh and fug baker mayfield, why not sign josh rosen and complete the 2018 set?

The panthers are not going to tag him and he is not going to want to be tagged. Rhule and co would most certainly give him a 5 year 150mil+ deal.

Bro if that is balling out then we can agree to disagree. He wasnt even in the top 15 qbs in that year

No I am asking you and the others, if he has a year like 2020 or slightly better and we maybe just maybe get a wildcard spot are you comfortable giving him a new 5 year massive deal? Thats a simple question. You going all in with Baker fuging mayfield because I have seen enough of this doofus that I dont want any part long term with him.

theres 3 scenarios, you left off simply average What if he has a 2020 type average year? Winning 8-9 games. What the fug do you do then? Keep rhule, resign baker, let him walk, franchise him? Like I said its not a plan just creating issues down the road