mrcompletely11

I think you probably should have looked at youngs rushing stats before you knock strouds

we would have gone to 3 and kept moore if we were in love with AR

Thats an A+ draft, would like some more line help but I would take that draft all day every day

Purdys career may be over before its started. His injury for a qb is pretty brutal

vegas -300 stroud

Why in your opinion are there not more qbs that are sub 6ft if a small frame doesnt matter?

Um, no it doesnt. Not at all actually

wait, you are being serious?

Where did I say anyone was getting fired year 1?

Is the knock on stroud going into the draft his frame and the issue of injury like it is for Young? I am not seeing it anywhere

His leash is a lot longer with stroud then it would be with young if he is the choice and say gets injured 6 games in.

So? Is this a real question? And flutie had several major injuries

exceptional? You sure about that?

Ill be more intrigued then pissed

If Fitt and Reich are acknowledging the size concern and if they draft young and he gets hurt thats a wrap for them. Seems like stroud is the pick.

Young is most certainly not in the mold of the pocket passers of Stroud, Manning, Stafford or Flacco.

Sweet Christ

well there it is then and should pretty much end this debate

There is a reason there are not a gluttony of small qbs in the nfl and I think you know the reason for it. If size didnt matter then you simply would see more. They get weeded out, hurt etc at the lower levels. Everyone agrees Young is the abnormally and I dont want to spend the #1 on an outlier of all outliers.

If thats true then you have to factor in him going to the SB with pocket passer manning and going to the playoffs with pocket passer Stafford. As a coordinator he worked with Flaco and won the SB. I think its fair to say he has a type.

Sure you cant live in fear but you can also make educated decisions. And the fact that no qb has ever been that small should absolutely factor into the equation. Again IMO, the kid is just too small to be taking one overall especially considering what you gave up to get there. 17 games is a long time and is hard on everyones body.

Thats all well and good but he is still going to get hit. He is still going to get flushed from the pocket etc. I dont think anyone is doubting how good of a qb he is, its just the anxiety of him playing 17+ games for 5+ years. No matter how fast he gets the ball out or how he processes he is still going to get whacked a bunch and for me personally I just dont see his frame holding up

Well, the 5-10 Young hasn’t gotten any taller. And it’s unclear whether his combine weight (204 pounds) changed since he declined to get measured or step on the scale at last week’s pro day. Scouts aren’t necessarily concerned about batted passes for Young, who can change his arm slot and find throwing windows. But there are durability worries given his slight frame. https://theathletic.com/4349599/2023/03/27/panthers-big-board-nfl-draft/ whatcha hiding Bryce?

That would work. Arthur smith and his running game could be a nightmare if they unlock richardson

This is momentum now of talk that the falcons are taking a hard look at richardson. I really hope that doesnt happen and he goes to the afc or outside of our division on the oft chance that he hits big.