Jump to content

PNW_PantherMan

HUDDLER
  • Posts

    8,624
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by PNW_PantherMan

  1. The term that we are working towards here is "replacement level".
  2. Exactly. I think a lot of people have this image of a bad QB in their head, and Bryce doesn't fit that image. But just stack him up against the other 31 guys 1 by 1 and it's tough to find many that make me glad we have Bryce.
  3. Can you name 8 of the 32 starting QBs that you would put below Bryce?
  4. Nikishin is legit. I didn’t really doubt it but damn.
  5. Pretty much everyone is nowadays
  6. He has been clearly visibly upset on the field and sidelines a number of times. I thought he would have forced his way out last season but his hammy put him on IR.
  7. Yea but you're not supposed to trade 2nd round picks for them or give them big contracts in FA lol. But I guess we did a lot better on giving Baker a shot. Hardly cost a thing. Which makes you think. If you could get a guy like Baker for next to nothing, why wouldn't you?
  8. The alternative is spinning the replacement level QB wheel. Not particularly exciting either. But we should at least bring one of them in this offseason.
  9. I think people are too invested on both sides. The reality is that the rookie contract is a time window. That window is running out. It's possible that Bryce gets his own Flutie Flakes when he's 32 years old, but it's probably not gonna be with the Panthers.
  10. At the end of the day, I just don't think there is much evidence to suggest that Bryce Young is significantly above a replacement level QB. I don't think it's that controversial. The level of whatever is going on in this thread to suggest people don't have eyes is just insane.
  11. It's not difficult to see how Caleb's eccentric personality could rub teammates the wrong way.
  12. It's not even a particularly nuanced opinion, yet it seems out of reach for so many.
  13. Being a football wasteland of an organization affects everyone differently.
  14. See I knew I was a genius when I bet 1 dollar on us making the Super Bowl.
  15. In that situation, if he were to breakout in the 4th year after we didn't pick up the option. I would be completely okay with that. We basically lose out on 1 year at 26 million but give out a big contract one year earlier. Hypothetically, I have no issue with that being given to a franchise QB.
  16. Yeah nobody even close to 24 in the NBA draft. Certainly not near the top. It's a completely different type of draft. It's all 18 and 19 year olds and they just draft on tools and hopes and dreams.
  17. It's just one game so I'm going to go ahead and overreact. If we've found a solid starter that can share starts with Freddie, then that could be huge for this team down the line.
  18. I’m in agreement here. I’m indifferent on the 5th year option. I’m mostly getting ahead of myself and alluding to a monster extension.
  19. In short, he has not proven to be above what could be considered “replacement level” QB in the NFL. You don’t pay a premium for replacement level players in a salary cap league.
×
×
  • Create New...