jb2288

yeah his physicals will be key

Correct which is why I was saying 39 and next years third. I would not give up a first for him even if we had it as I imagine that will be in the 14-18 range for us next year if we did have one.

and for that cherry picked interview there are 10 more that would disagree

Boy does he have that right

https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/36296254/sources-commanders-decline-chase-young-2024-option Would you all give up #39 and next years 3 for Chase? I think they will hold out for a 1st, but not sure if they will get it.

I have him at 5 also but drop Hardy, add Allen

As someone who watched every Ole Miss game Corral played in you REALLY don’t wanna go there and argue about completion percentage. Dude ran a HS offense with tons of quick short passes and screens

The numbers are valid dude

Fixed it

lol waiting for all the stroud bros to tell us how the test means nothing

This post has everything... kudos, seriously. Comparing a quarterback with a linebacker? Check. Comparing a coach with an on field player? Check. Saying Stroud would be a better pick because he's easy to move off of if a flop? Check. Peak Huddle.

While I agree with you, outside of this board and a few niche tweeters nobody sees CJ as a top 3 prospect. QB obviously gets a huge boost but there’s a large gap between BY and CJ

You gotta factor in the risk though. You know what you are getting with these other guys. Half this board thinks BY is gonna be a bust, the other half think CJ ceiling is Kirk Cousins

That's wild. Unless I'm misunderstanding the question.. just the #1 pick this year? Gotta add Herbert, Lawrence, and maybe Hurts.

that just helps his argument in this very specific niche BMI convo. The shorter you are, the stockier. 5'10 190 will be a higher BMI than 6' 190

while i don't think BMI tells us anything, OP did do his BMI of his Alabama playing weight of 190 and its still higher than Stroud

What? They’re prospects you even said so yourself. Of course there are elite prospects with elite traits. Any college player can be a bust but you draft based on college production which stroud and young both had elite careers.

I did. and linked mine. where's yours? hard to back something up when you just make it up on the fly

Lol prove it. Cause nobody agrees with you

I also would reply with only a gif if called out and can’t back it up cause I made it all up

Wait a minute let me get this straight. You said BY has a noodle arm and when asked to back it up you link articles that say “Young’s arm is strong enough” “velocity is good” it isn’t madden you clown, 95% of the QBs who come and go aren’t going to have the arm of Josh Allen, Dan Marino, and Anthony Richardson. That by no means equates to a noodle arm. I can’t believe I even have to explain this to you

Lmao okay I’ll bite. Link these reports where “every scout said arm strength is a concern”. I’ll go ahead and add mine where Tony Romo says arm strength and deep balls are both good https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/news/bryce-young-nfl-draft-2023-scouting-report-prospect-profile-nfl-combine-results-pro-comparison-more/amp/

75% for Reich teams

It’s not a lie. Again the consensus is if BY was 6’2 he would be the no question #1 pick. There’s a reason for that, he’s the best NFL ready QB in this class. That in no way says CJ is a raw prospect, Bryce is just viewed as the better all around QB as of right now if you aren’t concerned of his size.

Literally no professional scout, gm, or organization has said he has a noodle arm. Why you making stuff up?