Jay Roosevelt

If we had Derek Carr at QB right now we'd likely have already clinched the division. He's a solid QB. That said, in the long run we can do better.

At this point who the fug knows.

This is exactly why we need to go get a young offensive-minded HC. A good one can make a pedestrian QB look really good and a good QB look top-tier. Baker is an example of a pedestrian QB playing really well. Jalen Hurts is an example of a good QB playing at an MVP level. Both are examples of how much a good offensive mind at HC matters when it comes to QB play and development. Shane Steichen needs to be at the top of our list. I don't know if he'd be interested in us if a team like the Chargers with an established franchise QB has an opening, but we damn sure better try to lure him here.

Steichen + Anthony Richardson is my ideal scenario. We'd probably need a bridge QB (Minshew?) for a year but that's a hell of a combo to build the future of the franchise around.

This x 100.

I get the feeling this game will determine whether Steve Wilks gets the HC job full-time, one way or the other.

Jeff blew it on a Saturday.

Brock Purdy = Trevor Semien = Gus Frerotte = Case Keenum = Taylor Heinicke = Matt Cassel = Jacoby Brissett = Bruce Gradkowski = Charlie Batch = Rodney Peete = Chad Henne =

I'm torn on this. On one hand, there's no doubt that Steve Wilks HAS earned the job. Given the circumstances he's done far better than anyone should have been rightly expected to and there's no question he has shown the leadership ability to be an NFL head coach and is loved by the players. However, I'm still not sure it's the best move for the franchise long-term. The fact is we're almost certainly going to be drafting a QB next year in the 1st round. Whether it's by staying put and seeing who falls or by trading up and giving up a bunch of future draft picks to do it. Whatever else we do this offseason we MUST get this right and that starts with putting a staff in place that can develop whoever this QB is going to be. Frankly, I'm not very confident in Wilks in this regard. I certainly trust him with the defense and developing those players, and his approach to the run game has certainly worked. But when it comes to QB - especially if we miss out on a more pro-ready prospect like Bryce Young or C.J. Stroud - we really need a staff who is capable of developing whoever we pick and in that regard having a defensive-minded HC is going to be, I fear, to our detriment. Let's say we miss out on Young and Stroud and instead end up picking a raw "tools" QB like Anthony Richardson. Would you rather have some failed former HC-turned-OC and/or QB coach developing him while Wilks oversees from a distance or would you rather have a young offensive mind like Shane Steichen as HC having a hands-on role in developing him as our new franchise QB and building an offensive scheme designed to get the absolute most out of him? If I knew we could end up with a pro-ready QB like Bryce Young then I'd be much more supportive of Wilks as the long-term answer. I just worry that having a defensive-minded HC will limit our ability to develop a less NFL-ready option, which is looking more and more likely like what we're going to end up with.

I wish I knew exactly how they grade RBs. For a position so dependent on the OL's performance how do you grade the runner? I get yards after contact and broken tackles but how do you quantify vision? And do you take points away for playing behind a good run blocking OL?

I've been in full tank mode since week 3... but fug it. Let's win the goddamn division.

Sounds oddly familiar...

Justin Fields can't throw. If we should have drafted anyone over Horn it's Micah Parsons.

It doesn't matter, though. Because any good offensive staff is almost certainly going to get hired away to be head coaches in relatively short order if they produce results here. That's the real benefit to having a good offensive-minded HC. You always have that mind in the building regardless of who else is on-staff. Andy Reid is the perfect example. If you can get the right HC/QB combo then you're set for the long haul. If you only get one side of it, then you get what we saw with Ron Rivera and Cam Newton. Maybe some short-term success, but in the long run it likely falls apart. I'm not entirely convinced we won't see a repeat of this in Buffalo in the next few years.

This is true and exactly why we don't want Steve Wilks being our head coach after this year. See also: Staley, Brandon.

The biggest mistake was not trading up to take Justin Herbert in the 2020 draft. That may have been as much as Hurney decision as a Rhule one, but clearly the signing of Teddy Bridgewater played a role. If we don't sign Teddy then maybe we're more open to moving up for Herbert come draft day.

This is the Josh Allen comp, forget Levis. Richardson has as high a boom/bust factor as you're likely to see.

NO retreads.

God, I hope not. Nothing against Wilks but we need an offensive-minded HC who can develop our new QB.

This x 1,000.

I feel like Richardson stands to benefit a lot more by returning to school. He could be the #1 pick in '24 with a good year.

From PFF: If nothing else comes from this abortion of a season (other than firing Matt Rhule, of course) at least we appear to have FINALLY found ourselves a stud left tackle for the future.

I think a lot of people were so traumatized by Matt Rhule that they actually bought Steve Wilks as the long-term answer even though he clearly never was.

But Wilks and P.J. are the answer!!!