Jay Roosevelt

If I'm forced to choose between generic coach A and B I'm going with the one with the offensive background simply because I trust him more to develop a young QB.

When was that picture taken, though? He looks younger. If he was in high school when that was taken he could be an inch or two taller now.

I wonder if Tepper is trying to get a Wilks/Reich combo of some sort. One as HC with the other as a coordinator.

I'd say 60-40 Frank Reich only because Tepper seems to favor an offensive HC. I'd love either of them as coordinators; not sold on either as HC without a real game-changer at QB.

If it is Reich I hope we actually go all-out for a QB and trade up to #1 because my fear is the ultimate combo of mediocrity: Reich + Derek Carr. We'd be the Marvin Lewis Bengals; good enough for a playoff spot and even a division title every few years but ultimately doomed to the NFL's murky middle tier of teams not good enough to win it all but too good to ever be in position to draft that franchise-altering player. At least without getting insanely lucky in the draft.

In related news, Cam regrets not throwing Matt Rhule under one.

I swear we're bound to be mediocre forever. Both Wilks and Reich are the coaching equivalent of mayo on white. If we're going to have ANY shot at being more than a forever 9-win team over the next decade we'd better damn well NAIL the QB position this offseason because these guys ain't it.

If we don't make a move and trade up: HOU: Bryce Young IND: C.J. Stroud LVR: Tom Brady ATL: Desmond Ridder CAR: Will Levis Much will depend on who gets traded and to where and on whether Brady retires or not. I think Brady to the Raiders makes too much sense to not happen if he doesn't retire. If he does then I think Vegas is a prime landing spot for Aaron Rodgers. Carr to the Jets makes a ton of sense as well. IMO, the best case scenario for the Panthers is for the Colts to make a move for Rodgers or Carr or even Lance. They're the biggest obstacle for us in terms of landing Young or Stroud in the draft. I think the Raiders end up with a veteran QB rather than drafting one.

No coach should be expected to accept a 2-year contract just to get a job. If Wilks is the guy then you give him the same contract length anyone else would get.

If we go with Steichen it could end up being one of those situations you see every so often when a team decides to hire a coach and there is an agreement between both sides, but it's an open "secret" until after the Super Bowl. Think Kyle Shanahan to the 49ers.

It's QB or bust this year. We gotta trade up to ensure we get Young or Stroud.

People get being able to run the ball effectively and being a run-first team confused. This is a passing league today, but you do still need to run the ball effectively. The problem with the "ground and pound" approach of conservative coaches (mostly defensive-minded ones) is that it so often comes at the expense of an effective passing game. In this era, running the ball effectively means having a viable compliment to your passing game that you can lean on when you need to, not having "ground & pound" become your team's whole identity.

This game is a perfect example of why you want an offensive-minded HC over a defensive guy.

How is this even a question? Steichen/Stroud all the way.

Steichen.

I don't have a problem with Payton as head coach, but we better not give up two 1st round picks for him. I can live with next year's 1st, but anything more other than a 4th or lower on top of that is too much.

I still want Shane Steichen with Vic Fangio as DC.

Is it really because of Walkes' death or are they using that as an excuse to give Nicole time to undergo her diversity hiring training before they can resume interviewing candidates?

Before anyone starts suggesting Wilks as HC with Byron Leftwich as OC...

Being able to interview assistants from playoff teams in-person immediately would help speed all this up.

Two 1st rounders is too much. Just hire Steichen.

I feel like "settling" is an appropriate word for how I would feel if we hire Steve Wilks. He's fine, but he ain't winning any championships.

What does that have to do with anything in 2023? Do you think he's going to be paying defenders to target D.J. Moore in practice? I don't get it. We're hiring a football coach, not a boy scout. I'm sure his days of doing anything bounty related are long over.

We know. Lord. Do you really think that sort of thing was exclusive to the Saints? I'm pretty sure many teams had similar things going on, especially the farther back you go. I'm not excusing it, but I can assure you he wouldn't bring a bounty program with him to Charlotte. Personally I still prefer Shane Steichen, but I'd much rather have Sean Payton than Frank Reich or Steve Wilks, even if it means giving up a couple of draft picks.

I don't get the Tepper hate in this particular instance. Sure he's made plenty of blunders over the last 5 years, but he seems to be doing his best to get this hire right. I know a lot of you aren't on board with hiring Sean Payton for various reasons but looking at it from Tepper's POV he's the most qualified coach available with the best resume. I get not wanting to give up draft picks for him but it's not like Tepper is considering some nobody here. I mean it could be a LOT worse; he could be considering Jeff Saturday or Josh McCown.