-
Posts
1,890 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Huddle Wiki
Forums
Gallery
Everything posted by Jay Roosevelt
-
If we're going for a developmental guy I like Milroe just based on physical traits alone, but he's very raw as a passer. Allar is kind of the same thing, but a little more developed as a pure passer and less of a run threat. I like Nussimeier, but I feel like he sneaks into the 1st round. He strikes me as the best fit of the three you mentioned for what Canales seems to want to run on offense.
-
Oh absolutely. I'm talking about QB in the 1st round. If we don't go QB early we absolutely should be drafting a developmental guy in the middle rounds.
-
Hate to see that particular injury. Could very well be career-ending. At the very least he's likely played his last down for the Panthers.
-
Depending on how well Dalton continues to play the rest of the season I think it's entirely possible we pass on a QB and just re-sign Andy and build the team up for another year or two before going QB. Obviously much depends on where we end up picking. If we're picking top-5 we probably have to go QB; if it's 6-12 range it'll depend if one drops; below that we're probably better off just going WR/DE and either giving the 2nd round QBs a look or passing altogether. Having said that, my current QB rankings are: 1. Cam Ward 2. Shedeur Sanders 3. Garrett Nussmeier 4. Carson Beck 5. Quinn Ewers 6. Jalen Milroe
-
Sadly, I have to agree. I was as big a Bryce supporter as anyone, but there isn't any real doubt left at this point. I will say, though, I don't think the issue is Bryce's arm strength or even his size as much as it is that the things that were supposed to be his biggest strengths (running the offense, reading defenses, processing, accuracy) have ended up not translating at all. Had those things actually translated to the NFL, I don't think his size or arm strength would have prevented him from being a franchise QB. Unfortunately, they seemingly have not translated at all.
-
Does Andy have a fault in his game?
Jay Roosevelt replied to Gapanthersfan's topic in Carolina Panthers
Ok. -
Does Andy have a fault in his game?
Jay Roosevelt replied to Gapanthersfan's topic in Carolina Panthers
See, this SHOULD be true, but it's not. Because the state of QB play in the NFL is so bad right now that a guy like Dalton is likely better than half the starters in the league based purely on performance as opposed to value, which factors in things like age and draft picks/cap space used on a player. OBVIOUSLY BETTER: C.J. Stroud Jordan Love Aaron Rodgers Josh Allen Justin Herbert Joe Burrow Patrick Mahomes Lamar Jackson Brock Purdy PROBABLY/LIKELY BETTER: Jalen Hurts Matthew Stafford Jared Goff Jayden Daniels Tua Tagovailoa ABOUT THE SAME: Sam Darnold (I'm putting him here because I think it's likely he reverts to his usual play at some point; what we're seeing is more coaching/scheme than elite play) Baker Mayfield Derek Carr Kirk Cousins Dak Prescott Trevor Lawrence Kyler Murray Geno Smith Justin Fields CLEARLY WORSE: Jacoby Brissette Will Levis Deshaun Watson Gardner Minshew Daniel Jones TOO EARLY TO CALL: Caleb Williams Bo Nix Anthony Richardson -
Does Andy have a fault in his game?
Jay Roosevelt replied to Gapanthersfan's topic in Carolina Panthers
Pump the brakes now. Dalton is a very good veteran QB, but let's not act like he's the second coming of Dan Marino. But to be fair with how awful the QB play has been by the young QBs over the last few years (Stroud excluded) I think some of these veterans certainly do look a lot better. -
I have a admit, he did look massively improved today.
-
Y'all need to get off the Arch Manning hope train right now because that ain't happening. No chance that family (not to mention the league office) lets Arch play for any team that isn't on the "approved" list and you can bet your ass that ain't a list we're on.
-
This Andy Dalton/Dave Canales is legit
Jay Roosevelt replied to FutureDynasty's topic in Carolina Panthers
Evero is a great DC. He just has nothing to work with, and less after all the injuries. -
Official Panthers Bengals Andy Dalton revenge GameDay thread.
Jay Roosevelt replied to Zod's topic in Carolina Panthers
Good call to go for it; just didn't go out way. At least they're backed up now. -
Beck is hot garbage. I'm not sure I'd take him in the 6th round, let alone the 1st.
-
I can't fathom why they'd start Zavala over Christensen. I'm not sure I've ever seen worse OL play than what we saw from Zavala last year.
-
Cam Ward.....opinions (AKA A Thread About Shedeur Sanders)
Jay Roosevelt replied to Jmac's topic in Carolina Panthers
Go watch some of his Washington State stuff; he did not have that kind of time there and was still balling. -
Brady Christensen time.
-
Cam Ward.....opinions (AKA A Thread About Shedeur Sanders)
Jay Roosevelt replied to Jmac's topic in Carolina Panthers
His Washington State play is probably a better gauge, TBH. Miami is pretty stacked right now and they haven't really played anyone. But he has been great this year, obviously. -
Cam Ward.....opinions (AKA A Thread About Shedeur Sanders)
Jay Roosevelt replied to Jmac's topic in Carolina Panthers
I've been a fan of his for a while now. He's QB1 in this draft, IMO. -
I'm not trading him for a 4th, period. We have no reason to rush this process if we intend to trade him; come the offseason some team will offer more than that.
-
Honestly, even if we end up finishing with 4-5 wins I see that as a success if some of our young players show real progress (Ickey, XL, Brooks, and Sanders especially) and we can put together a solid foundation for whoever our QB of the future ends up being. That said, I think it's entirely possible we sneak into the playoffs if Dalton plays even at an average level, especially if Jonathon Brooks can come in and give us a spark in the run game mid-season. Not that Chuba is playing poorly, but that's a potentially deadly 1-2 punch with him and Brooks.
-
I can see us finishing 10-7 or 9-8.
-
How Many Games Before Dalton Loses a Start?
Jay Roosevelt replied to kungfoodude's topic in Carolina Panthers
I think we lose on Sunday, but keep it close. The Bengals will be playing desperate at 0-3.