WarHeel

My list: 2022 Roaring Riot Awards Winners Offensive Player of the Year - Yikes…you’d have to go lineman here but for sake of avoiding the double dip I’ll just say “pass.” Defensive Player of the Year - Frankie Luvu Rookie of the Year - Icky Most Valuable Panther - Bozeman Play of the Year - DJ’s end zone catch (and subsequent helmet removal penalty) Thomas Davis Panther of the Year Award - D. Brown

Let’s hear your nominees for 2022! Here is last year’s list for reference: 2021 Roaring Riot Awards Winners Offensive Player of the Year - DJ Moore Defensive Player of the Year - Haason Reddick Rookie of the Year - Chuba Hubbard Most Valuable Panther - Haason Reddick Play of the Year - "I"M BAAAAACK!" Thomas Davis Panther of the Year Award - DJ Moore Note: How/why the hell did we let the “MVP” walk…

Correct. And for clarification, my argument is you need multiple pieces. Not just a stellar RB who can do it all. Not just a better than average QB. Both can make you competitive but in isolation they are not going to win you championships.

Disagree. Would have likely been a very close game with a health Mr Irrelevant.

Eagles could have certainly been the better team overall but having your QB1 and QB2 go down in the moment doesn’t leave much for fair competition at that point. But that still doesn’t mean that CMC isn’t a game changer simply because he couldn't “win the game” for them in that moment.

I get that, but having your starting and backup QB get knocked out of a championship level game doesn’t necessarily equate to a player like CMC being invaluable because he can’t win the game for them in that moment. That’s a bit of a stretch.

Well you have folks saying they lost the championship game because they didn’t have a stellar QB and you’re saying they went on a 12 win streak because of the change at QB. So which one is it?

They were 3-3 and won 12 consecutive games after he signed. Purely coincidental though….championship caliber teams are generally 500.

Maybe so but that’s more of a nod to the Eagles than anything else

The only game this happened in for San Fran was yesterdays game which was due to both QBs going down with injury. You look at the 12-13 games before that and CMC was elevating everyone around him. If you want confirmation, look at Kittle’s numbers before AND after the CMC trade and get back with me

Doesn’t prove anything. CMC functions as a receiver grossly 30-40% of the time. He has consistently had the best hands on the team. You don’t think Aaron Rodgers would give his left nut for CMC in his stable?

Congrats. You just described every player in the history of ever.

We were still strongly one dimensional being a run first team with showed in at least 3 games to close out the season when Hubbard and Foreman decided to take a nap. Disagree all you want but he would have likely helped lead the 49ers to a SB with a 7th round QB had the entire QB roster not fallen apart. Because they knew how to utilize him.

Ask Aaron Rodgers how things in the modern NFL go when you lose all the talent around you.

Cute comment but once again the guy goes for over 100 yards on the ground and through the air and averages 5.6 yards per friggin carry. The Eagles are a force and the 9ers had a spectacular season with Mr Irrelevant at QB. That’s what “disposable” gets you.

A classic example of correlation not alway meaning causation.

You might be on to something

Douchehole was a little much. But you can’t go around waving the finger calling folks players only fans. I am a fan of players like CMC, Diggs, Kelce, etc but they’ll never come before my franchise. This thread is simply to debunk some of the arguments used to trade him away which I agree with in theory fiscally but I still don’t think we got the haul he was actually worth and Burns should be out the door as well but managed to stick around.

If we can’t produce with CMC on offense then who are we going to produce with? It’s not his fault he was used inappropriately.

He’s been healthy the majority of his career with a bad slump in the middle. I’ve been preaching this to you guys for a while now.

Read the whole thread douchehole. I’m a Carolina fan first and foremost.

What a fuggin finish that was!

You’re crazy. My wife drafted him in fantasy and he balled out literally every game all season. He had two off years. Prior to that, 3 full seasons of healthy ass kicking.

Tell me Burns should be gone without telling me Burns should be gone.