CRA

I tell you what, if I was a team that wanted CMC.....I would want him before Wilks put him through the meat grinder vs Tampa.

I tend to put the most stock in his momma CMC. Sure sounded like they hoped and were thinking a trade was coming.

I think CMC, Shaq and any older player has fair odds pending their agent can find something realistic. But there isn't much here to be desired on that front. I think we have forever overrated Jackson and I don't think others would really want him. They make sense. They aren't the youth. They are the older Icky, Moton, Horn, Chinn, Burns, Browns, etc are probably untouchable ones pending their isn't some in house drama/issue specific to one of them that they can't work past.

Career completion % - Heinicke TD/INT ratio - Heinicke Win % - Heinicke Most opportunities b/c of draft spot - Sam I mean it’s actually an easy call. Give me Heinicke over Sam on my roster. And that’s not an argument that I want Heinicke on my roster lol.

I mean, if you are Shaq, CMC, and dudes like that? This is their window to do something. So if they want a ring and a shot to compete you have to ask out. Simple as that. Rebuild is coming and their ages don't align with Carolina being a place they can do anything but collect a check from.

Hell, I'd take Heinicke over Sam Darnold.

I wouldn't be surprised if they are "listening" to offers because players are simply asking for trades at this point and their agents are being told to go find something that makes sense and we might do it.

I mean, if Chubba Hubbard turns into Adrian Peterson the next couple weeks we could easily trade CMC and extend Hubbard. Sam Darnold has never provided a steady hand from college to pros. He is the polar opposite of a steady hand.

DJ not getting open in McAdoo’s predictable RPO junk isn’t really about DJ though DJ has the Peppers issue. His lack of outward emotion is something fans use against him.

Why? they aren’t under contract. They aren’t developmental. And they don’t provide steady veteran play.

people somehow have forget how bad Sam Darnold is. just think about how bad he was. Now imagine a worse version of that. Because that is what Ben McAdoo provides

Not really about Jake’s QB ability and more about his ability to deal was with a mega personality and hot head. a young 89 just wasn’t going to work with a ton of QBs. Ones way better than Jake. Cam and an older and milder version of 89 weren’t the best pairing. Hence why 89 had to go. Cam was hitting his prime right when we parted with 89. And Cam went on to reach the peak of his career after that.

I mean, you can run the gameplan Wilks did with any QB. And then it doesn’t matter who you start. I mean, PJ sucks but this staff did everyone wrong last week. I mean, keep doing that and you are going to have problems IMO with others on the roster at some point. I mean you can let them play. With PJ and McAdoo you aren’t beating the Bucs letting them play. It will be ok. You don’t need the fetal position offense.

Gets weird though. I mean in reality vs a Madden create a team. Chemistry. Locker room. All that jazz often has a lot to do with special seasons. Not sure you could of paired a young 89 with a prime Cam. To an extent, 89 needed the personalities of Jake, Prohel, Moose, etc. But Jake was big IMO for Steve actually working out like he did. 89 paired with a lot of QBs likely doesn’t work. Especially that young version.

89 and CMC are simply nothing alike. I don’t really get the question. in their primes? I’d rather have a dominant WR than a dominant RB. I think the dominant WR can be more impactful overall. Especially in scenarios if your team gets down. same reason I’d probably pick Peppers over Luke. It’s largely the position. And Luke IMO is the best actual football player of his position IMO in our history. Others simply could be more impactful due to their position and also had bigger roles that extended beyond just their actual play.

And Steve said he would have asked weeks before Rhule actually got fired.

that's probably called hope. I mean, if I was CMC I would hope I got traded. This is his prime and it's going to lead to nothing pending he doesn't get traded and out.

I mean who doesn't have a podcast lol.

Shi probably has shown the most potential but Shi is a slot guy at this point. You can't just take that type guy and throw him on the outside. Then it doesn't work. Shenault falls into this too. He isn't the type WR you put on the outside because that isn't what he is. On the outside I think you simply rotate TMJ and Higgins on the outside.

yeah, we specifically need a receiving TE. Not a blocking TE.

I'm not a big fan of moving up in drafts but if we owned the #1 pick? I'd be okay moving up from the 33rd spot if there was someone great in the end of the first or middle. Using that 33rd pick plus something wouldn't be that massive of a cost. I mean, the Otah/Stewart year catches a lot of hell. But in reality, we hit on two super studs. One just couldn't stay healthy and you can't predict that.

biggest needs IMO are DE, then LB, then TE IMO. hell, you can find a Robbie Anderson type WR in the middle of the draft. League is slammed full of them. Most people don't make them starters. Bad teams do.

Icky is a rookie. On a painfully predictable and poorly coached O. And has looked decent given he is a rookie LT in that scenario. He isn’t even on the radar of things to complain about

We need penis egg shell

I know but if they aren't really counting/weighing those screen passes as real pass pro reps? The rush reps pretty drastically outweigh the pass reps. For example, 1 pass pro rep you get a A+ vs 10 rush reps you get an F on. You wouldn't get a C on the day. The rush reps count more.