CRA

Yep, you can’t grade every player on the field live. Hell, you can’t even see every player on the broadcast.

Lions game is nuts!

People can blast Evero every week, Leggette every week, defenders every week…..and it’s not hating the team. It’s wanting to get better. Bulk of the Bryce “hate” is simply knowing decisions are coming and have to be made……and we want the team to have a higher ceiling and be better.

If you are reading this thread, you would know I didn’t point to last week’s game. Someone once again overstating Bryce Young brought it up because Bryce can’t just have a nice game….every win select folks have an uncontrollable need to just start making crazy statements off it. Bryce wasn’t great today. Only on his grading scale is that great. He was fine today. Good game.

The point is merely there is a Bryce Young scale of play and a rest of the league scale. I don’t use the Bryce scale. there is no QB in the NFL we would claim played fantastic….losing to the bad Saints, leading an O to 17 points, with 160 pass yards unless there was some conditional statement made with it (like for a rookie, hurt or something).

Cam Newton was never outplayed by another QBs…..when he played fantastic. As you said Cam could play bad sometimes. Bu the claim was Bryce played fantastic. Shough wasn’t fantastic. Shough was good for a rookie.

I know I addressed the claim of being fantastic vs the Saints. So, either you think he was fantastic…..or you just want to disagree with every statement I make for the sake of it

Calling Bryce Young fantastic vs the Saints is some of the ballsiest trolling I have seen. I’m to eat on that note. Panthers get a win and you guys really go to work lol

The claim was Bryce Young was fantastic last week vs the Saints. I said no. Not sure what your post is trying to argue by saying Cam played bad sometimes lol

Depends on the windows….Teddy had it good in 2020. After that? CMC largely hurt and you find stuff like PJ Walker won games with Foreman as his RB, TMJ as his #2 and Shi and Shenault as the #3/4. Sam did too.

We played the Saints last week and the best QB on the field was a 2nd round rookie. We punted 4 straight times in the 4th quarter as the Saints came back to beat us. fantastic? I wish someone would share the official Bryce Young grading scale so we could understand it

Yeah, you probably don’t want to use random numbers, that’s why you can look at all 32 teams and determine what is average pass production in the NFL. Then, you can obviously see where we stack up vs the league. Let me know what you find out.

Canales basically ask Bryce to make 2-3 throws per game…..and outside of that he is playing safe conservative football. It’s been the formula the past several weeks…..and it largely means games are going to be close. Went our way today. Same formula went the other way vs the Saints

It’s still all on a Bryce Young scale of good. He wasn’t good vs the 49ers. He wasn’t good vs the Saints. Thats 50% post Atlanta. Canales managed him as a bad QB only really letting him throw in absurdly favorable 4th down scenarios (he made 2 great throws on dumb playcalls. Props for those but it doesn’t erase how Canales had to managed him all the other snaps). That’s an odd game at best. Bryce is consistent. Thats sort of the point the haters make. He didn’t turn a corner week 17. Just like he didn’t turn a corner in the random Atl game this year.

I mean we are toxic. But vs Twitter, Reddit, etc? Nah, this is kid friendly lol.

This is an old message board. It’s probably the least toxic setup you can find in today’s world. Social media is way more toxic and that’s where most sports talk is today. the average age here is older and big % of folks that don’t want to mess with modern social media sports talk. Predicting it will bite the dust one day isn’t much of a call but I mean one day it will

I’m not rooting for XL to drop passes in game. But if the primary goal is to win down the stretch…..we would be better off if he was inactive. I’m not wanting Bryce to throw INTs to lose the game. But zoomed out and our big picture in mind, he ain’t it

No. Real fans only root against Evero. And XL. And Corbett. And any other player that strikes their mood any given Sunday. Never Bryce! Please take notes on that

Bryce has broken your brain/logic, friend.

To all the people actively rooting against the Panthers (Evero and XL haters)….. *did I do that right or is it all just a carve out only for Bryce?

No. We don’t need a week off. We aren’t well coached. We don’t actually have a good offense or defense. This team needs reps and to keep improving. You don’t get better not playing.

Heck no.

Folks need to quit saying it’s rigged. They gave us one there. That was an easy hold to call that helped Bryce extend that refs just stink, they ain’t trying to help Tampa

He makes plays vs man. Did it last year. Doing it this year. Did it then with a big one. Thats not an insult. It’s pointing out where he does well.

Man coverage and blitzing….thats Bryce’s perfect storm to make plays dating back to last season. It’s sitting in zone that neuters him