CRA

The bar for Bryce Young isn’t the same as PJ Walker. It’s his 3rd year. He is the #1 overall pick and he throughly got outplayed twice by a second round rookie on a worse team. I just answered you. Not being able to outplay and be better than Shough is why it’s his fault. And no sane human watches those 2 games and thinks Shough didn’t outplay him….and Shough wasn’t out of this world.

It’s simple. We all saw with our own eyes. The best QB on the field Sunday was a 2nd round rookie in his 6th NFL start….and that QB is on a worse team. and Bryce was the #1 overall pick, is now in his 3rd season….and again, in both matchups the Saints QB was the best QB on the field. We have a QB problem

Bryce. We have seen him w/ 2 coaches. The flaws will forever be the flaws. The ceiling will forever be the ceiling. Limitations will forever be the limitations. Give Canales 1 season w/ a downfield thrower. I mean, I don't like Dave and his style but that's the only thing that makes sense IMO big picture. We know what Bryce is. What know what Evero is. See a single season of Dave w/ a QB that fits his scheme. Heck we would likely be a double digit win team with just some nobody like Shough.

at this point Bryce is Brenton Bersin and anyone that isn't ready to move on is Jerry Richardson. Dude is not a NFL starting QB. We can keep playing as one but it doesn't change the fact he doesn't belong. and yeah, Bersin could make a catch every now and then too.

Shough doesn't have better talent around him today than Bryce had his rookie season.

I mean, the rules are the rules. Slides are legal. You blow up a sliding QB and it's called every single time in the scenario Shough was in. Should QBs be allowed to slide? Do I like that rule? No. Because I think sliding actually puts QBs in greater risk of serious injury and puts defenders in a horrible spot. But as far as what happened Sunday? There was no other way for the refs to call it different than they did.

There is a formula to win with Bryce Run, run. Play D and hope you can capitalize on an opponent who makes mistakes…..and ask Bryce to make like 3 throws. The exact same gameplan was used the week prior vs the Rams. Thats how you have to call a game pending it’s not 1 of the Atlanta games (and he only gives you one of those a season vs them)

yep. Extra yards. Burn a couple seconds (because if they missed the FG you don't want to give the Panthers time for some miracle attempt). It's a just a good call by the Saints and we handled the moment poorly. Tough spot for the defender in real time. But that's football.

I mean, he didn't flop. He got lit up.....and then sold it on top of that just to make sure.

2 NFL HCs say it does.

There was a game earlier this season where he did his slow crumble and it made a lot of the local coverage talking points.

The QB slide should be banned because it actually does the opposite of the intent and puts the QB in extreme danger and at risk in football. Some of the worst hits are QBs that slide getting decapitated. QBs are much safer IMO if afforded no protection and have to act as RBs. *much like earlier in this season, Bryce still doesn’t know how to do the baseball slide. He did that late slow crumble/fall.

I’ll wait for you to address which one you have a problem with. If you are looking for real time verification you can go to gameday thread lol until then…

If you think my takes are terrible, that’s a high compliment. I’d be worried if you agreed and thought they were smart. I would need to do some soul searching.

I watched Shough outplay Bryce by a fair margin. Again. I watched Bryce make 2 horrible throws on the same drive as his 1 good throw Canales is limited in how he calls a game because he has to factor Bryce heavily Bryce and Shough giving themselves up weren’t comparable we should of kicked the FG What take did you have a problem with?

Raiders moved on from Russell long ago Bryce. Bryce is at 40+ starts. Russell never sniffed that. Raiders had less egg on their face than we do and didn’t give up the same assets for their bad QB

It depends on the context surrounding statement. There have been times and context where he has been the worst. I also have zero interest in doing what you do right now. Have a night

Having to correct your inaccurate Matt Rhule take….isn’t wanting to talk about your Scott Fitterer defense. It’s just correcting the record.

You have been been told he is the worst starting QB since 2023. Anyone technically worse has been benched, team moved them or they are new and don’t have the same time in yet. It’s not hard to understand. You can simply choose to pretend you don’t. Zero teams have stuck with a QB as bad as Bryce over the past 3 seasons.

Let me clarify, your Scott Fitterer arguments were horrible. That is sincere. It was at the time as well. So is not wanting to hear them ever again. That is not poo posting.

No, I nor anyone here needs to ever listen to your horrific Scott Fitterer takes ever again. And you sadly still want to defend them it seems we got your present day horrific takes instead to painfully digest

We had the 30th ranked pass attack in 2024. We are average less yards in 2025. We would be worse vs that field. What little production we get out of it is masked by an overflow of really bad pass attacks elsewhere in 2025.

Matt Rhule was a dead man walking going into year 3. He wasn’t in full control and the GM. I’m not rehashing your horrrible Scott Fitterer takes

I mean, yeah, this is correct. This wasn’t a horrible Bryce day. It’s was your average day from him. Which is below average QB play. And it means the rest of the team has to be really dang good.

Not true. Your boy Scott Fitterer was a disaster that overlapped Rhule and was big part of the mess. why it was argued Fitterer should of left with Rhule and we should of had a clean slate from their stupidity. You know then, when you were screaming Fitterer was good.