X-Clown

Agree with everything you said here except that Brady didn’t win a SB with Caldwell. Caldwell was his #1 WR for one season, in 2006 when Manning finally beat the Patriots and then won the SB. He dropped 2 passes in that game. If anything though it proves your point further.

So that’s the only way you judge a players career? Does that mean that Andy Dalton is a better QB because he’s been to three?

This sounds a lot like those people that never liked Cam Newton from the get go and were never going to have their opinion changed no matter what he did. There is ZERO chance that Jared Goff could have made those two throws with all that was on the line to Kupp at the end against Tampa and a 10 point 4th quarter comeback against the Niners to even make it to this game. There’s a reason McVay and Snead were willing to give up two first rounders to dump Goffs contract, and bring in Stafford. I guarantee you there’s no point in the last 4 weeks they’ve regretted that call.

If he retired today, I’m not sure. If he played at a high level for 2-3 more years, I would say yes.

So is he above average or is he a bum? How is it possible to be both? Sam Darnold, Jared Goff and Carson Wentz are bums. I get you adopted the bengals and are emotional after they came up short, but stafford came up big after losing Beckham, having his running backs average less than 2 yards per carry, and having to throw prominently to *checks notes* Brycen Hopkins and Ben Skowronek when the bengals were triple covering kupp. He’s not on the level of mahomes, Allen, Herbert etc…as he’s a little older but he’s also not some guy that was just along for the ride either.

Incorrect, he proved a lot of people wrong who believed he was the problem in Detroit. But just as in Detroit he wouldnt be good enough to carry a a bad team and even worse coaching staff if he were here.

It could be really soon if we get the next coaching hire right. I don’t think any of us thought that after 2001 we’d be in the SB in 2 years.

Gotta be one of the legit worst takes I’ve ever seen on this site, and I’ve been reading since 2007

I never understand people that would say that and actually mean it especially if you’re from and in the Charlotte area. Chances are it’s a Redskins/Commanders or Cowboys fan that hate a team came to our area and that some of their fans left their teams and love to reminisce about the good old days 30 years ago when they won their titles, and when it was more socially acceptable to comment on how attracted they are to 15 year old girls.

No, see above

You might want to start by not believing everything you read from a Facebook/Twitter post 5 years ago from some random dude who thinks players that kneel before the anthem are uppity. https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/are-there-871-convicted-felons-currently-playing-for-the-nfl/

Rhule could be the next director of morale for the Bills

Kupp has played twice as many games this season than CMC has combined in the last 2 seasons.

Well so much for that because he’s interviewing for the OC job with the Bears today. I wonder why he’d do that

He’s still has 3 years on his contract w the saints. They’d have to get compensation for that to happen.

My post said zero about his weight/body type, I guess the pictures must have spoke to you differently

You missed the point

This is what a rockstar looks like

I think it was more about philosophy. Rhule wants to #establishtherunatallcosts. Maybe he will give Jeff Davidson a call.

https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2022/01/18/report-pep-hamilton-declines-interview-with-panthers/ must not want to be a rockstar

Cousins is a Viking, not a Lion. You might have been thinking of Jared Goff. Cousins had a fantastic system around him in Minnesota, I don’t see that translating here where he could put up those kind of numbers. Seems like he be a better fit on a team like the colts, Steelers, or broncos that has a ready made situation for a QB at his career stage.0

Rhule sucks, but for everyone pining for McCarthy, this is why you don’t want him.

The chargers would have put up a much better fight, wish that game ended in a tie

Zylstra?