Jump to content

Doc Holiday

HUDDLER
  • Posts

    8,861
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Doc Holiday

  1. If it makes you feel better I haven’t thought we’d be any good since before last season, hated Teddy Bridgewater signing and Darnold remains to be seen. part of the reason I’ve barely posted at all this season.
  2. I can sum up the Horn pick with one example, would you rather have Luke Keuchly in His prime or Josh Norman in his prime? I don’t know anyone here who wouldn’t take Keuchly, and that’s my point MLB > CB. Plus if Horn does turn into what we hope he will be once he is off his rookie contract he it will be cost prohibitive to keep him. we had a chance to pick the best LB’er in the draft but instead took a CB(that may also be the best CB). we have also been trying to replace Gross for years and we had our chance again and passed again. I’m sure Horn will turn out fine. I’m not knocking the player, only that we had far bigger needs and spent the pick on a Luxury position. CB’s in the first are completely fine when you have other positions of need filled. LT and MLB are just straight up more important without question. then our second round pick as I said before issue again isn’t talent. But he was drafted to address a need that “might” arise in a year. And that’s why it’s a terrible pick. You a draft of fill current needs, here I’d rather we had addressed Tackle or maybe drafted a Safety. Positions we need help at now. Instead we drafted what would be our 3rd or 4th option at receiver with CMC (who everyone is forgetting is on the team and has had 100 catch season before) back? Terrible pick based on team needs. the only pick which truely addressed a current need on the team in a big way was Christensen. And he’s probably going to be a project for now anyway.
  3. I didn’t argue the talent, only that you draft for current needs, not one that may appear in a year. We made this mistake before with Butler. Wasted a first on him. draft to address your current needs.
  4. Overall draft Grade: C 1. Horn. Based on Horn alone it’s an A. But based on our team needs this pick was an F. Wasting a top 10 pick on a CB when you have serious needs at more prominent positions can’t be said to be anything but a failure of a choice. 2. Marshall. Again another wasted pick, you pick to address current needs, not one that may arise in another year. Spending a 2nd on a maybe 3rd option on our WR roster for this year is an absolute joke. F 3a. Christensen. Solid pick for the 3rd, actually addresses a team need. A+ 3b. Tremble. A Meh so what Pick, better options available, really could care less about the pick. anything after the third s a project so i will it grade that, but overall grade for the Panthers is a Big fat F. My most hated draft in recent memory. I loved our draft last year. This year? Terrible.
  5. I’m not saying believe women without question, I work in law enforcement and know better than that. I also know you don’t normally get 20+ complaints when you’re acting like a saint.
  6. They are not the same situation. Ben had 1 accuser. Watson has 20+.
  7. I will say this the people trying to argue the case to clear Watson, why do you care? He isn’t coming here, not after these allegations he would be lucky to play football again at this current rate. find something else to focus on than a lost cause.
  8. No, I do work in criminal justice though, all states may have different names for the same thing but they all operate about the same.
  9. the SBI would be it. They may take it because of the high profile status of the case but as far as jurisdictional issues they can deny taking it until the HPD refers it to them, the SBI can’t just take over without a good cause of being requested by the HPD. a plaintiff can’t exactly decide which agency will investigate their case because that is dictated by the location the offense occurred. while I am personally suspect of the validity of the case because so far there has been no evidence given, or shared with the proper authorities. Which is leading me to believe it’s BS. Criminal conviction/charges would only further the civil case, so a lack of that so far would tell me the evidence is questionable at best. But I also reserve Judgement until after these issues are resolved. I know many here think we were close to landing Watson, but I’m not going to ignore the gravity of these accusations just because he was close to becoming a Panther.
  10. People say games aren’t fixed, but I remember the Panthers scoring 3-4 TD’s on a single drive that kept getting called back on phantom calls after Katrina. also can’t tell me the no calls on all the helmet to helmets on Cam weren’t a fix either!
  11. In my opinion. 1. QB 2. LT 3. MLB any other suggestions to me are laughable. It’s these by a mile, everything else isn’t close
  12. Apparently you’ve suppressed memories of Jimmy Clausen.... you know the last QB that Weis spoke highly of coming out of college. Lol
  13. https://www.espn.com/blog/new-england-patriots/post/_/id/4822261/charlie-weis-raves-about-mac-jones-as-potential-patriots-qb-of-future only old school fans will understand why....
  14. This 1000% I don’t feel bad for players being cry babies. Millions of people would trade places with them a d rather have their tough choices to make.
  15. Only direct quote I’ve heard from him was anywhere but NE. Not exactly how the story is spinning it.
  16. yeah, everyone is pretty much late to this party at this point. its going to crash eventually as people who are sitting on more money than they make in a year bail. if youve made life changing money and dont bail at this point youre insane. some idiots are gonna hold out too long and will lose their ass
  17. we have 8 not 7, bad info people jumping to say something without any backing. im glad it didnt work out then 8th is too high a price for Stafford. Stafford 5 years ago id given 2 first and then some. not today.
  18. So here is my take on the win situation: if we get: Watson - super bowl contenders long term solution to an issue Stafford - playoffs, short term solution to an issues Draft - we will see in 2 years, possible bust, possible ok, possible franchise QB. I see trading for a QB as a lot less risky than drafting for one. If we get either of these qb’s in a draft outside of LT we need to go all in on defense, namely LB’er and CB.
  19. It didn’t extend his contract only moved his money around. Nobody complained when he signed his original.
×
×
  • Create New...