You aren't having a debate. You literally haven't said anything other than in "your eyes" he isn't better. Then some rando gave you your second data point. I mean....how about this, have you watched any of his games this year?
I see the issue, I am not counting his rookie season where he didn't actually play minus a few snaps of garbage time.
So by your math that would be his 4th year.
Well, those stats certainly disagree. He is very much having a better year.
The "tie" is not actually a tie. The cells clip and round the decimals to one significant digit even if the input is more.