kungfoodude

McCarthy also had far better QB's playing for him. He also was often criticized as the Packers coach for not meeting expectations(fairly or unfairly). Not sure I would necessarily pin the Dallas issue on a specific person.

I would put a healthy some on him heading back to TV.

For the record, I did not include Payton in my personal list because I am becoming convinced he isn't that serious about taking a job this offseason.

Curious to see how this matches the Panthers. This is multiple choice, obviously.

I am not sure consecutive 12-5 seasons meet the threshold of "poorly coached." The 2021 playoffs loss was a disappointment as a higher seed at home but they were supposed to lose the game that they just lost. So, while those crunch time play calls were both unfortunate I do think both McCarthy and Moore are getting way too much shade thrown at them. Consider that had Dak Prescott not heaved two insanely bad INT's this very well could have been a comfortable Cowboys victory.

You are aware that this narrative you are pushing is going to look very silly if the Eagles win this weekend, right?

We have some talent on the roster but it is not a stacked roster like some seem to believe. Good defense, good OL, couple of weapons on offense and that that's about the gist of it. Nothing elite about any single aspect(maybe the kicking/punting). It's a decent spot for a coach to have a quick turnaround if there is a plan at QB.

No, it really isn't.

I am glad that it is highly unlikely anyone in our organization has that point of view.

I gotta be honest, if the question of how to develop Matt Corral comes up during any of these interviews, we can just go ahead and consider this franchise as doomed. No 3rd round QB that has never played an NFL game should ever factor into something as important as a head coaching interview.

As always, if you are having to force coaches on your head coach, he doesn't need to be your head coach.

There is no QB in the NFL that looks at our roster and says, "Man that TMJ guy will be a stud!" It's basically Moore and a bunch of JAG's. Not something enticing for a FA QB.

Tend to agree. Deep pool and WR is very weak for us.

It is very rare that bad owners get lucky.

Technically Wilks would be considered a new hire.

This process is very much longer than the last already. I also believe the only remaining candidate we have been linked to in the playoffs(that hasn't declined our interview request) is Shane Steichen. But he has also already interviewed with us.

You are getting to this mountain via several levels of pure speculation. Just.....chill. Try and remain calm. Let the coaching search play out before we try and speculate about free agency and then the 2023 draft and then the offseason and then the preseason and then the regular season and then the postseason and then the 2024 offseason and then we can finally get to 2024 draft speculation.

I think we have more waiting to do, unfortunately. I can't say I am upset that they are taking their time with this process considering what a disaster the last coach hiring process was. It is tough as a fan to be in this limbo where you really can't plan or effectively speculate on the offseason until this gets resolved.

I think he probably wanted complete control in New Orleans too. You can get that impression with some of his interviews about specific things that happened while he was in New Orleans. I doubt he is willing to come back unless he can shape the front offices the way he wants them.

I would highly doubt it is about money. More likely power.

No one feels persecuted. You are just making a mountain out of something less than a molehill. More like a tiny ant hill. None of this has happened. None of it is likely to happen. Also both of those guys probably aren't going to end up being the caliber of prospect that you think they will be. Probably won't end up on the Saints either. It's a lot of worrying about very little at the moment.

This entire saga seems very contrived. I don't think these teams are as interested as the Payton rumor mill machine makes them out to be. I also suspect he is basically asking for the keys to the franchise ala Jim Harbaugh.

You aren't reading what I said correctly. I said take all those scouting reports about freshman and sophomores with a grain of salt. More like a grain silo of salt. It's based on very limited inputs(not a lot of film) and those evaluations are going to progress as the careers of those players progress. For every Trevor Lawrence or Andrew Luck there are dozens of Spencer Rattlers, who don't improve or get worse and all that early luster fades away very, very quickly. That's basically what happened to almost the entire 2022 QB class for a recent example. So, yes....it is WAY too early to be calling shots on Maye or Williams. They very well may end up being the next big thing but they also might end up being the next Sam Howell, a guy that had all KINDS of hype due to early career success but he just didn't really improve his NFL skills because he wasn't at a place that develops QB's well at all(hence why EVERYONE should be wary of Maye). Also, most of the people weighing in on these guys are media bobbleheads and amateur analysts. Doesn't make their opinions worthless but they aren't going to tend to hold as much weight as actual professional NFL scouts. That's why we see some stark disparities every single draft season between the "media draft stock" and the actual position that a lot of these guys are drafted. TLDR: just chill on the super young college QB hype. Let that play out and we will see what happens.

If you look at the destinations and evaluate them logically.....there is nothing particularly great about any of these options. The Broncos MAY have a QB or they may have a guy that has gotten exposed now that he left Seattle. Plus that includes the fact that they trade a bunch of draft capital away to get him. We are in QB purgatory with very little chance of resolving that easily or cheaply. Not to mention that while we have talent, there are literally almost no players in our core that have even experienced a winning season. Go around the league and aside from maybe Arizona, there aren't a lot of "ready made" winning situations. These are a lot of fix'er uppers. So...what's the rush? Why would there be a rush on his part? That's the thing that doesn't logically track for me. Unless he is just chomping at the bit to get back to the NFL(in which case I don't think he would have retired anyway) then he has the benefit of waiting until his ideal scenario presents itself.

So you can't read?