Mr. Scot

​I'll take actually watching a game, a player and a team over a stat sheet ten times out of ten. You can't judge OL simply by QB hits without factoring in how mobile the QB is. The whole notion is ridiculous. And there's no stat that effectively quantifies mobility (no, QB rushing doesn't work for that). Stats were what told us that David carr was a great QB because he had a great completion percentage, but when you looked closer you realized all he threw were short, high percentage passes. Anytime someone comes to me telling me they can judge football teams and players by stats alone, I proceed from there with the assumption that the person in question doesn't know much about football.

​Two words... Second read.

Same reason anybody has an MVP season, honestly. Because he played well.

​There's a hell of a lot of debate for Romo and Roethlisberger.

And by the way. who is this twit?

Names on that list that I would most definitely debate: Roethlisberger, Flacco, Romo, Ryan, Wilson and pretty much everybody after "also". (Kaepernick, Stafford, Cutler...seriously?)

There's ALWAYS debate, especially with some of those names. Worth noting that ut depends a lot on the criteria you use for determining the 'better quarterback' too.

​You're a pessimist? Maybe a contrarian?

​Thanks dude. Always sad to lose friends.

​I remember old Darth. The 'most evil bastard on the board' he once said. I've forgotten Bastet's real first name, sadly. I am praying for her, though. Did they have any children?

Alv, do you know how Bastet is doing?

Mark and I were mods together on the original Panthers boards. I had heard he was sick, but held out hope he'd make it. Terrible news. Rest in peace, brother.

What if you can't read? I mean we do have Saint fans on here. What about them?

Of the options presented, I like 'Pie Chart' the best.

Pretty much. If you went pure BPA, then yes, Watt is gonna be considered by most to be a better overall player than Newton. Pretty hard to argue that without being a homer. But when you factor in that Newton is a franchise quarterback, the value shifts dramatically.

You can apply that comment to about any post he makes and it will still be accurate.

Wrong franchise. (plus they made him super creepy now)

Elway used to do that a lot.

Gee, I wonder why he thinks that

So who's this? ...... If I dye her hair red and ask her to hold up a hamburger, does that make her easier to recognize?

Not a matter of "or". I have no doubt both of these things will happen.

He did it to make fun of him. I'm not sure our resident dimwit has caught on to that fact yet.

He shows that in every post he makes. Fixed.

Some of them aren't even that. These days, a decent number of them are really just lip-synching dancers.

When the classic rock stations are the ones playing "your song", it's time to acknowledge you're old