Mr. Scot

This offseason is a damn reboot

Someone posting on a Panthers forum?

I'd hope it's more like the 49ers. Adam Peters runs the personnel side of things. John Lynch runs everything else. I'm good with that as a model.

Lemme think about it... No

NFL General Managers have traditionally been CEOs, handling pretty much everything within the team, part of that being roster management. What we may end up with Is someone who has that title but isn't really over the personnel side of things. And as mentioned, I'm fine with that. Just don't give me an analytics guy making football decisions.

That's what I'm waiting to see. The title doesn't matter so much as the job description does.

I don't really have a problem with it. It is fair to point out that it's unusual, and yes it's pretty obvious that it comes from a position of insecurity. But then, it's not like we didn't already know how people were looking at us.

Depends on how you look at it. What it makes most clear to me is that it's understood how people see the team, and David Tepper in particular. That's not a bad start, but you still have to do something about it.

You want an honest answer to that?

If the ultimate end is that they have one person in charge of all that roster and personnel decisions while another handles everything else, I'm okay with that. What I don't want to see is an analytics guy being put in charge of personnel decisions.

This quote... That, presumably, was done out of fear of being turned down—that rejection would get out, which would bolster perception that coach and GM candidates are leery of working for Tepper (which is just the honest truth right now). ...would seem to indicate that a common (or at least expected) answer is "no"

Copied from his 1/10 mailbag column: From Jeff Murray (@jeffmurr): Who do you think will be the next Panthers GM and HC? Jeff, this is one of the teams that I think will veer from the traditional structure, to something a little more like what you might see in another sport—which is part of why you bring in a consulting group like Sportsology. That company’s executive director, Mike Forde, is a name to know, as he will have some influence on where the Carolina Panthers’ search goes. Forde is a former top executive for the Chelsea FC of the Premier League. So I think there’s a decent chance, as we said Tuesday, they hire someone from the operations side (cap/analytics) of a team to be their next GM, and then pair that person with incumbent assistant GM Dan Morgan If you look at Carolina’s interview list, you’ll see more folks from operations than scouting on it. On the coaching side, I do think things are a little less predictable, but one thing I was told by a couple of people is that David Tepper will be looking to check, say, 10 boxes rather than just one (offensive/quarterback) this time around. My concern here with all this would be whether the Panthers are worried about the right things. To kick off its interview process, Carolina reached out to candidates, through different channels, to see whether they’d accept interviews before officially putting in slips for them with the league. That, presumably, was done out of fear of being turned down—that rejection would get out, which would bolster perception that coach and GM candidates are leery of working for Tepper (which is just the honest truth right now). So their list, essentially, includes people who’ve already agreed to interview, rather than the full list that they’re looking at. Which, to me, reeks of an organization being concerned with the wrong stuff—and, ironically enough, is a reason why a candidate would be cautious about pursuing either of those jobs. I do think Tepper can be a really great owner. He’s incredibly smart. But it feels like he’s become too wrapped up in a lot of things that new owners are often concerned with, from image and optics to being seen as forward-thinking to constantly changing his mind. There aren’t great signs yet that’s changed in 2024. But there’s still time to fix that.

They don't exactly seem to be hurting at the moment.

And yet they got tired of him. See also: Owens, Terrell

Kind of an odd thought since we haven't inquired about Weaver that I've seen.

Sorry dude, but I think Harbaugh is a way better college coach than pro coach, especially for the long haul.

Why does it matter this much to you that I be on board with it? Mr Completely has long been obsessed with me (pretty well documented inferiority complex there). I'm not sure why it matters to you that I join this particular cause, though.

Also, possible Atlanta may be dumping their GM as well.