A lot of talk about what kind of coach the Panthers should hire (if Rivera is out). Let's look at where the rest of the league is. ___________________________________________________________________________________________________ First off, offense vs defense: OFFENSIVE COACHES: Andy Reid Bruce Arians Chip Kelly Doug Marrone Gary Kubiak Jason Garrett Jim Harbaugh Joe Philbin Marc Trestman Mike McCarthy Mike McCoy Mike Munchak Mike Shanahan Rob Chudzinski Sean Payton Tom Coughlin DEFENSIVE COACHES: Bill Belichick Chuck Pagano Dennis Allen Greg Schiano Gus Bradley Jeff Fisher Jim Schwartz John Fox Leslie Frazier Marvin Lewis Mike Smith Mike Tomlin Pete Carroll Rex Ryan Ron Rivera SPECIAL TEAMS COACHES: John Harbaugh ____________________________________________________________________________________________________ Next question...What were they doing before they were hired for their current job? NFL DEFENSIVE COORDINATORS (10) Chuck Pagano Dennis Allen Gus Bradley Jim Schwartz Leslie Frazier Marvin Lewis Mike Smith Mike Tomlin Rex Ryan Ron Rivera NFL OFFENSIVE COORDINATORS (7) Bruce Arians Gary Kubiak Jason Garrett Joe Philbin Mike McCarthy Mike McCoy Rob Chudzinski NFL HEAD COACHES (5) Andy Reid (formerly a Quarterback Coach) Jeff Fisher (former Defensive Coordinator) John Fox (former Defensive Coordinator) Mike Shanahan (former Offensive Coordinator) Tom Coughlin (former College Head Coach, NFL position coach) NFL POSITION COACHES (3) Bill Belichick Mike Munchak Sean Payton COLLEGE HEAD COACHES (5) Chip Kelly Doug Marrone Greg Schiano Jim Harbaugh Pete Carroll OTHER (2) John Harbaugh (NFL Special Teams Coach) Marc Trestman (CFL Head Coach) NOTES: - Bill Belichick had been both an NFL head coach and a defensive coordinator before becoming coach of the Patriots. - Bruce Arians was an interim head coach while Chuck Pagano was ill, but his official position was still as an OC. - Tom Coughlin and Jim Harbaugh both had experience coaching in the NFL before getting their college head coaching jobs. - Likewise, Pete Carroll had been an NFL head coach twice as well as a very successful defensive coordinator before coaching USC. - John Harbaugh has experience coaching in all phases of the game, but made his name in the pros coaching special teams. - Marc Trestman had several years experience as an offensive coach in the NFL before going to Canada. ____________________________________________________________________________________________________ And finally, let's take a look at who's been competing in - and winning - the big game over the last decade: 2013 - John Harbaugh defeated Jim Harbaugh 2012 - Tom Coughlin defeated Bill Belichick 2011 - Mike McCarthy defeated Mike Tomlin 2010 - Sean Payton defeated Tony Dungy 2009 - Mike Tomlin defeated Ken Whisenhunt 2008 - Tom Coughlin defeated Bill Belichick 2007 - Tony Dungy defeated Lovie Smith 2006 - Mike Tomlin defeated Mike Holmgren 2005 - Bill Belichick defeated Andy Reid 2004 - Bill Belichick defeated John Fox 2003 - Jon Gruden defeated Bill Callahan 2002 - Bill Belichick defeated Dick Vermeil 2001 - Brian Billick defeated Jim Fassel 2000 - Dick Vermeil defeated Jeff Fisher ____________________________________________________________________________________________________ Breaking it down... Numbers tell you the best position to get an NFL head coaching job from is still a pro coordinator (DCs beat OCs by a narrow margin). Guys like Nick Saban, Bobby Petrino and Steve Spurrier made it tough for college coaches to get a look for a while there. Jim Harbaugh and Pete Carroll may be helping rebuild their image, though truthfully, it's kind of a misnomer to refer to Pete Carroll as a college coach. He had loads of experience as an NFL coach (including two head coaching stints) but his rep had taken a hit before he did some image rehab at USC. Harbaugh and Coughlin aren't exactly pure college coaches either. Coughlin was a pro position coach before going to Boston College. Harbaugh had a few years on the Raiders staff, but was a pro player for way longer than he was a pro coach (his last year was with the Panthers). Doug Marrone and Greg Schiano have pro experience too: Schiano spent three years as a Chicago Bears defensive assistant (Ron Rivera was also on staff for the last two of those) and Doug Marrone had a three year stint as OC for the New Orleans Saints. The only pure college coach on the list: Chip Kelly, whose grade so far is most definitely an incomplete.
Click here to view the article