islandhopper81

One game where he had a nearly flawless game but you already claimed he choked in? Last December was more than one game. Dallas had to win out to insure their playoff appearance. Tony Romo had the highest December QB rating in NFL history an the team went undefeated. December is more than one game.

Dude played with a punctured lung. And won. Played with broken ribs and broken bones in his back. You have no Idea what you're talking about.

Romo had a 143 rating in the GB game. Without the Dez catch.

Yeah you did. You said how can anyone think that winning football games was dependent on one player then proceeded to attack Romo based on team success. You're now disparaging the team based on quality of wins in the NFL. That's an argument that shows a lot of naivete. Which anyone who thinks Romo is not a good QB is full of.

All of them.

You just completely contradicted yourself. And at least this season, the proof is in the pudding. Dallas has lost every game without Romo. They've won every game with Romo. They've lost every game where they had the lesser QB. They've won every game with an advantage at the position.

I'm replying to the OP who stated that he wasn't in the top 5 of QBs the Panthers have faced. He's wrong. Horribly wrong. And it's amusing in a post supposedly attacking uninformed fanbases.

Like Trent Dilfer? SB are a team measurement. Tony Romo is one of the best QBs in the NFL. Arguing otherwise makes you look like someone relying on media narratives for your knowledge.

Long term maybe. Thursday Tony will still be much better than all of those guys outside of Rodgers. He has the numbers and the Ws. People think he's elite because he's 3rd all time in QB rating. Has the most 4th quarter comebacks since becoming the starter. Is coming off the season in which he led the league in YPA, completion percentage and QB rating. Hasn't lost a game this year. Has won games at an 80% clip over the last two years. You know facts and such. Now back to your regularly scheduled programming.

Since the start of 2014 Cam 16-8-1 Tony 16-4 If you think he's terrible you haven't been paying attention.

What QBs are you ranking ahead of Romo? Bortles No Mallet No McCown No Winston No Wilson No but some people would argue it. Bradford No Luck Ok Arod Ok Mariota No Cousins No There's no way Romo doesn't crack the top 5 QBs the Panthers have faced.