Jump to content

backINblack28

HUDDLER
  • Posts

    486
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by backINblack28

  1. 48 minutes ago, OldhamA said:

    I mean what have Young or Stroud won in College?

    21-4

    24-3

    6-7

    i'm not all about caring that much about QB W-L records, but as a pretty objective just Panthers fan rooting for the Panthers to select the right dude at QB1, one of these things is not like the other.

    This is to mostly ignore that asking 'what has (a heisman winner) won?" being an objectively ridiculous question. Comparing the 3 players performances against UGA is also a fair (something all of them have done) indicator to me, if we're also going to ignore consensus mock drafts/experts/majority of the huddle/literally everyone having a 1-2 of either Stroud/Young or Young/Stroud for argument's sake here.

    There may not be a lot of QB consensus among our fanbase, but I personally don't think we're flipping a coin that starts with "there's a possibility here that in the future, AR15 could be as good as Young or Stroud!"

  2. 9 minutes ago, Prowler2k18 said:

    I agree. Richardson to me is Cam 2.0. Athletically superior to the other QBs in this draft but a project. The difference with Cam was he not was only similarly gifted physically but the best QB in 2011 draft. This time, there are a few NFL ready QBs whose skill set are ahead of Richardson at this point. Wouldn’t have been upset at all if we considered him at #9. At the top position we gotta go with Stroud or Young.

    Agree with this--Cam had a lot of in the pocket and accuracy questions from pundits, but what people couldn't argue with was the fact that he came in and destroyed the SEC by himself in 1 year. 

    Richardson did not.  The fact that he didn't elevate a UF team that leaves plenty to be desired I think validates some of the questions about the raw aspect to his talent, and for me, it plays similar to Trey Lance coming out where the raw intangibles and talent were very attractive but that it's unrealized to this point makes your point about him being a great value at 9, but too much of a gamble after trading up to 1.

    • Pie 2
  3. 26 minutes ago, DavidEng said:

    Correction, if Rags win they would be tied in points with the Devils but 1 win behind.

    that's still objectively better for us winning the metro.  Rangers being within 3 points with a game in hand is better than the Devils being within 1 (given we lost).  We have ROW tiebreaker on NYR, but not currently on NJD. Us getting to 105 points and the Devs/Rangers both being at 100 would be better than us at 105 and NJD at 102. 2 teams at 5 points back with 7 to go for them and 8 for us, I like those odds.

    • Pie 2
  4. Guy is still really young.  People (read: mad Habs fans) wanted to bury KK before he could buy a beer and although he's been inconsistent he has also shown the ability to take over games.  This stuff can take time, especially when their confidence takes a hit in these markets where it's as if they're playing for the Yankees and held to impossible standards.  I think he fits in well to our system, and his youth means it would make sense for him to get a prove it deal with us to take over a roster spot voided by someone like Stepan.  He just needs to get a streak going.  Hell, a lucky bounce for a goal in round one and he could all of the sudden be the Foegele/McGinn/Max Domi spark that you knew you needed but didn't know they'd be the one carrying it out

  5. we've played Tampa so well this year they ought to be raging mad at another opportunity cause we made them look like aged trash in the last game and they were trying to bait fights. expect a chippy one. let's close it out.

    • Pie 2
  6. 16 minutes ago, glenwo2 said:

    If Blackwood plays, yes.

    But Vitek has been more than just serviceable.

    We expected him to be just average when we signed him, and he had been way more than that this season.

    Remember that any goaltender can go on a Hot streak in the playoffs, as well. 

     

    So long as Vitek is doing his thing, the Devils have a greater shot of winning and going as far in the playoffs as they can.

    Though i don't see any team in the East getting by Boston this year.

     

    we've ran into the rangers several times, and they made the ECF last year, whereas the devils weren't there. for us as a 5x year playoff team that finally add experience to our resume, the pick your opponent option is likely always going to be the team that is new blood/hasn't been there before.  

    while you're not wrong about Vitek/goaltending getting hot--while that's possible for anyone, it's been the thing that has kept Carolina from advancing, and it's not the random names.  It's stacking what has been league average goaltending (and specifically Freddie's injury last season at a bad time) up against Vezina candidates/Shesterkins/Tukka Rasks of the world. a young team with Vitek / some inconsistency behind him is more attractive than facing NYR again. it's not personal. NHL East fans have clamored for us in the playoffs to their peril too so it's just bulletin board material for NYD but at the end of the day, the prospect of playing one of the worst two playoff teams while you and NYR beat up on each other is the obvious best case

    • Beer 1
  7. give it time. the devils have been struggling too. adjusting to the injury itself takes time, both from figuring out line combinations to getting over it mentally in the locker room. we're going to see this team's guts sooner rather than later, and I feel like what we saw in Philly leaves plenty of room for optimism.

    • Pie 1
    • Beer 1
×
×
  • Create New...