Jump to content

Castavar

HUDDLER
  • Posts

    9,055
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Castavar

  1. Just trying to tone down getting into heated arguments when others have a different opinion than me. It's happened a lot before and turned into personal arguments and it never goes anywhere with legitimate football discussion. I understand what you're saying and of course I have some amount of homerism, but I still stand by what I said. Cam played great considering what he had to work with against an all-time good defense, especially when compared with how Rodgers played and how Peyton played last year. The Brady comparison may be a stretch because he had a good game and I made it clear that I didn't think Cam played way better than him, but I do believe an argument could be made that Cam played better in the divisional game than Brady did in the Super Bowl when you consider every single factor. It's just 2 games though, I'm not saying Cam's better than Brady or anything like that. Every QB has great games and bad games. I just like how our future looks with how well Cam played against such a great D. That game was lost by our defense, not our offense when everybody thought it would be our lack of scoring that would lose us the Seattle game.

    Oh ok.

    I respect that perspective. Yes, Cam played a very good game. However, I still think that Rodgers and Brady played better against them. I thought that both Brady and Rodgers recognized certain situations better and made way better decisions. If not for the Packers D and special teams collapse, they would have won fairly easy, As for Cam, I also thought he played a good game, but in order to be a championship caliber team, he has to play better than good. But (like you said), it is pretty hard to do that considering those variables you mentioned. I still think if we want to win a superbowl, Cam has got to take his game to another level, and now that we are going into this season with the best supporting cast he has had, I can't wait to see if he does take that next step. I think he will. Sorry about the confusion.

  2. Of course he wasn't perfect and that INT was bad, but Brenton fuging Bersin was the #1 option on that play and he tripped running his route. He tried to do too much and force it Dickson when he should've thrown it away or taken a sack, but we never should've put him in that position to begin with. And even with that pick, compare his game to Manning's in the SB, Rodgers' in the NFC Championship Game and Brady's in the SB and take a look at the receivers and o-line and offensive coordinators on each team... And Cam and Rodgers were in Seattle while Brady and Manning were neutral, and there is a difference. Cam playing better than Brady did may seem questionable on the surface but think about it. Cam played against a healthy secondary in Seattle, with our mediocre WR group (Philly hurt) and our poor o-line and Shula while Brady played with his large amount of weapons and above average line and a superior coaching staff, at a neutral field and against a secondary with Sherman and Thomas hurt and Lane out of the game. All Brady did was dink and dunk and let his players get all those yards for him, and that's why he had so many completions and a high %. His yards/attempt was terrible. Alex Smith could've played just as well as Brady did that game considering all the other factors.

    You are simply ridiculous. Outside of Gronk, who are these "large amoutns of weapons" you speak of? Not to mention his clutch drive to put them up and his clutch 3rd down plays to keep drives alive. Brady absolutely exposed that defense, Seattle D didn't know what hit them. And you are trying to discredit him because he dink and dunked all game, but THAT IS HOW YOU BEAT SEATTLE. i get it, everybody hates Brady, but you are just being too naive and a homer. If Cam had the exact same game Brady had (including the game winning drive), we would talk about that FOREVER. Don't be such a homer.

    • Pie 3
×
×
  • Create New...