WUnderhill

Maybe I’m not understanding the numbers exactly correctly so somebody can correct me if I’m wrong. It appears to me that players may get higher “True Accuracy” scores just by attempting deeper throws. If true, it’s just a hard number for me to put a lot of weight in. That’s not to say it means nothing. It also appears that one of the most important numbers would be the DIFFERENCE between raw or true accuracy and adjusted accuracy, but we don’t get a total adjusted accuracy number because it is broken down into 3 categories, so I would be interested in knowing if there is a total adjusted accuracy number. I find it interesting that Stroud has such great accuracy numbers, yet slightly higher than average catches requiring adjustment. Does that mean his ball placement is not quite as elite as advertised? I don’t know. His contested catch % is slightly higher than average, and pass defended percentage is lower than average, which could again be an indicator of him throwing to his first read regardless of coverage and his receivers playing the ball better than their coverage. These are cool stats to look at and they could be interpreted several different ways. I trust the staff we’ve assembled to properly interpret this kind of stuff within the context of the film.

Wow did I offend you? Imagine me suggesting that the talent gap between his WRs and the opposing secondary may be less in the NFL, or that there are smarter coaches and players in the NFL. This may come as a shock, but the NFL playoffs are different than college.

Great information, thanks op. I don’t see anything that should change opinions. AR has accuracy issues, Bryce Young pretty good at just about everything but lacked explosive plays, Stroud very accurate and his receivers and line were great (holy crap 0.89% drop rate). I think it’s clear you can design an offense for Stroud and tell him where to go with the ball and he can get it there. But that’s always been clear. If I had to guess, I think he will probably look like a really good regular season QB who struggles in the playoffs.

Let’s all just ignore Fitterer’s comments that Tepper is allowing he and Reich to make the decision and assume the complete opposite.

Why is this happening?

Panthers MO

Vikings up next.

I think the other score he is talking about might be Anthony Richardson’s. There had been reports of him scoring in the high 80’s-low 90’s previously. The silence from Stroud’s camp on this is deafening.

I think only about half the teams in the NFL pay for access to the S2 test. It is this guy’s worst nightmare for his test to tank the stock of a top prospect before he has full buy in from every team. Once he has full buy in, no college QB would dare decline the test. But until he has that, he doesn’t want the college QBs to start seeing reasons not to take it. He is an extremely biased source giving extremely vague information.

Good point, he could mean the senior bowl. So yeah in that case he is likely referencing Hooker. People should find it strange he finds a way to explain Hooker’s score but not Stroud’s. The guy affirms in the interview that they don’t want the scores to be used against the QBs. He’s telling you he has motives to keep it all rainbows and sunshine to your face.

S2 guy: “The LIST of scores that I have seen, TWO of the those scores are not accurate…somebody could have gotten a list of very early scores…one of the athletes on that particular list I know had a difficult time making his way to the all star game.” 2023 East-West Shrine Bowl QBs (college football’s “all-star game”): Tanner Morgan, Aidan O’Connell, Tim DeMorat, Dorian Thompson-Robinson, Tommy DeVito, Chase Brice NO CJ Stroud. So, TWO inaccurate scores, the only one he gives any hint on who it is is NOT CJ Stroud. He mentions the LIST of scores HE has seen. We don’t know what that list is. The list of scores from McGinn’s article does not include any of those players at the east-west shrine game Goat boy: “Final Say…the S2 scores that were leaked aren’t accurate” He thinks you’re too dumb to actually listen to what is said. There have been few in huddle history who have deserved to have their thread making privileges revoked as much as this guy.

That was mock drafts, not the player rankings. People mocked Stroud to us for a bit but Young was still #1 on big boards. I was talking about consensus on rankings I thought the other guy was too.

I don’t get why people think this. Young has been the consensus from the start.

So you mean OP just made up numbers to sell a narrative? I’m shocked. I thought he wanted to have a genuine discussion with no ulterior motive. What a shocking and unexpected revelation. Thanks for actually doing the research and posting these. I can’t imagine why OP completely ignored the question.

Oh hey guys we got this guy all wrong. He’s just a concerned citizen. Wow so kind and noble of you to be worried about his safety. I hope Bryce has your number so he can lean on you if anything ever goes wrong. What a sweetheart.

Yeah, totally rent free because I mention you in a discussion to which you’re relevant. I just made a comment about Matt Rhule too because he was the topic of a discussion. Is Rhule rent free too? Oh you know what, I talked about Drew Sanders and BJ Ojulari, guess they’re rent free. Good one.

He and Rivera both with the “I’ve got to watch the film” poo. Like do you have no recollection of what happened? Annoying af, glad this guy is gone.

There are very clearly a few people who are not looking to have honest discussion, OP included, and goat boys shenanigans have pretty much poisoned the well for all Stroud supporters. I was actually back and forth on Stroud and Young, but after it became clear that Young was the pick some of us accepted it, and a select few buried their head in the sand and tried to discredit everything and make this place a complete poo show.

Lol, spamming is making one post then responding to failed insults, got it. “Guyz, why aren’t you “contributing” to my anti-Bryce Young thread after I spent days spam pooing those I disagree with in the 100 other anti-Bryce Young threads made by panthergoat?”

Lol, talk about “contributing” coming from you who does nothing but spam poo people who disagree with goat boy. Whose alt are you?

Lol, as if these 2 doofs will show their faces if Young is the pick.

In your head, are people reading this and thinking you’re super cool and witty?

Gosh, if only we had somebody on staff as smart as you. It’s really a shame none of our professional staff can see what you see.

Just saying, the other day I looked at the first 8 search results for 2023 big boards and 5 of 8 had Young as the top overall prospect and the lowest he was ranked as a prospect was 4th with all of them having him as the #1 QB. You’re free to your opinion on whether he’s the top prospect, but there are many who have him ranked above Carter, Anderson, and Robinson.

They’re probably reading this board like “Jfc, how much clearer can we make it? Alright let’s leak to another reporter I guess.”