-
Posts
9,530 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Huddle Wiki
Forums
Gallery
Everything posted by SmokinwithWilly
-
How long will the Carolina Panthers rebuild take?
SmokinwithWilly replied to jayboogieman's topic in Carolina Panthers
Agreed. My first thought was 3 years after Tepper sells the team. -
What is the benefit to benching starters for the preseason?
SmokinwithWilly replied to hepcat's topic in Carolina Panthers
If BY were to get hurt in preseason, say season ending, we would have to seriously consider another QB in the draft even if he were capable of returning. Year 3 would be an evaluation year again and year 4 we have to consider 5th year option. We're not going anywhere without a QB so if one comes along we like better than BY, it's just business. Let them compete. But dont hamstring the team because you're afraid of hurting his feelings. I'm actually a little more concerned about DC than BY. If DC doesn't work out and goes full Frank mode, BY will be on his 3rd head coach in 3 years and that HC will definitely have zero ties to him. This team needs some stability somewhere. I hope we find it. -
Likely the only interest in the Panthers I'll have during the regular season is to see who they're playing next so I can pick up the opposing defense in fantasy football.
-
What is the benefit to benching starters for the preseason?
SmokinwithWilly replied to hepcat's topic in Carolina Panthers
What I fear is the excuse that they didn't have enough time with the new system, coach, GM, players, etc. I fear trying to build a system around him that avoids the use of common sense. I fear we are trying to invest everything in a QB that didn't even rank in the top 32 last year. That is downright terrifying given our history under Tepper. If we end up with a top 3 pick, and I believe our chances are better than 90% we will, not taking every opportunity may very well lead us to passing on a QB should there be one worth taking, or taking a player to specifically help BY instead of taking the best player to help the team. But my greatest fear is that this owner and FO can't or won't admit that a mistake was made, if indeed it was, and it's time to move on. The more opportunities that are available to evaluate his performance, the better that evaluation has the potential to be. -
What is the benefit to benching starters for the preseason?
SmokinwithWilly replied to hepcat's topic in Carolina Panthers
BY needs to be playing. Forget draft status. Based on his play alone from last year, he should be competing for a starting spot and nothing should be guaranteed just because he was the number 1 pick. Based strictly off performance, we've got a late rounder/udfa starter, a dinosaur qb2, and some practice squad rejects as our hopeful starting QB. No team should ever feel comfortable going into the season with that, but we're good. -
What is the benefit to benching starters for the preseason?
SmokinwithWilly replied to hepcat's topic in Carolina Panthers
What it screams to me is they're ok with failure. How can anyone say they're trying to improve the team when the most important position on the field has zero competition. Or that could just be the plan. If BY gets hurt, put in Plummer and it's a straight shot to number 1. -
Anyone interested in a Huddle Fantasy League this year?
SmokinwithWilly replied to ACobra289's topic in Huddle Lounge
Sent. Let me know you got it. -
Anyone interested in a Huddle Fantasy League this year?
SmokinwithWilly replied to ACobra289's topic in Huddle Lounge
Can you give me the last 4 of your phone number to make sure I'm paying to the right place. -
He knows. He just does it to piss you off.
-
What is the benefit to benching starters for the preseason?
SmokinwithWilly replied to hepcat's topic in Carolina Panthers
Rodgers has a SB ring and 4 MVPs. BY has 2 wins. Not really the same comparison.- 144 replies
-
- 12
-
Will there be Zima?
-
I heard they're passing out braided belts at the home opener.
-
Why Dave Canales needs live reps with his first-team?
SmokinwithWilly replied to jayboogieman's topic in Carolina Panthers
-
Unnecessary Bluntness podcast on Canales and preseason approach
SmokinwithWilly replied to Icege's topic in Carolina Panthers
I misunderstood what you were saying. However I will say that with the urgent need to evaluate BY in a competitive setting, putting him behind a weak center is doing us a disservice. So what if we waited until next year to draft a center if BY can't be evaluated well due to constant pressure up the middle. Determining if BY is a franchise QB is the only thing that matters right now. He looked like a late round or UDFA last year, not a number 1 pick. A lot of that can be attributed to horrendous oline play as well as his own mistakes. But we have to know. If we end up with a top 3 pick, we have to know whether or not to move on. A shiny new RB doesn't change that. We needed a C through FA or the draft, the draft being ideal because of the quality available at the same spot. Not knowing if BY is a franchise level QB is a far worse finish to the season than going 0-17. -
Unnecessary Bluntness podcast on Canales and preseason approach
SmokinwithWilly replied to Icege's topic in Carolina Panthers
We've seen over and over again rookie centers having immediate impact and being good players while we keep trotting out broken down versions of a center and constantly talk about our poor oline play. RB was a luxury pick. Time after time, Dallas prior and Philly now, are perfect examples of plugging any RB behind a good oline and watch them have career years. We just spent a small fortune on a franchise QB, and when it comes time to actually get a real center to call the line and block, we did what we've watched fail over and over again. The Saints drafted McCoy. As far as putting too much on BY plate, Mr. Irrelevant is getting it done in SF, so the number 1 pick with the best processing brain since Peyton Manning should have no problem. -
Unnecessary Bluntness podcast on Canales and preseason approach
SmokinwithWilly replied to Icege's topic in Carolina Panthers
And that's what's really sad. We spend a small fortune on our offensive line between Moton and G's, Ickey as a top 10 pick, and the guy to lead that unit is coming of 2 leg injuries and is being moved from guard. What good does it do to spend all those resources and leave a gaping hole right in the middle? Sure we can pick a cast off from another team if Corbett doesn't work out. But taking cast offs to anchor the middle of our expensive online doesn't make any sense. -
Anyone interested in a Huddle Fantasy League this year?
SmokinwithWilly replied to ACobra289's topic in Huddle Lounge
Injured reserve would be in again