-
Posts
11,055 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Recent Profile Visitors
SmokinwithWilly's Achievements
-
You underestimate the stupidity of our owner. Bryce shouldn't have got the 5th year but he did. He hasn't had back to back franchise QB level game performances ever. Our franchise is being built on hope and a determined owner who will not admit he made the wrong choice.
-
By the time you draft a QB and design and drafting the players to build around him, especially with the trade up we did, the rookie QB contract window is almost over. It's better to build the system and find the QB to drop into it before the 50-60m per season bomb drops or just draft from your position without bankrupting your future.
-
Kept Darnold and draft JSN. It's not like there weren't possibilities if we had been mildly intelligent.
-
Championship Round Playoff Thread
SmokinwithWilly replied to kungfoodude's topic in Carolina Panthers
Puka broke up that pick same as he did today on a near pick. I give players credit for making plays. Stafford has a SB win and is a perennial playoff QB while we have 8 losing seasons in a row. I'm no Rams fan but we'd be damn lucky to have gotten him instead of LA. -
Sam Darnold can’t throw the ball past the line of scrimmage.
SmokinwithWilly replied to hepcat's topic in Carolina Panthers
His 1st 2 coaches were Adam Gase and Matt Rhule. 2 HCs for 2 of the worst franchises this past decade. I'm not that surprised actually. Takes a couple years under competent coaches to get up to speed. He's getting there. -
Championship Round Playoff Thread
SmokinwithWilly replied to kungfoodude's topic in Carolina Panthers
That offense can score easily in under 2 minutes. We gave them the ball back with too much time on the clock. -
Championship Round Playoff Thread
SmokinwithWilly replied to kungfoodude's topic in Carolina Panthers
Take the points there. Only down by one. Even if they score, you can still go for the 2pt -
One QB that struggles to see over the line and one that will need cataract surgery at some point during the year. Good times.
-
It's only going to get worse with NIL and transfers. These QBs aren't NFL ready and they need to sit. I think if we see them sitting the first year or 2 after being drafted, it will change the QB NIL situation as well.
-
The right answer was re-sign Darnold, sit at 9 and let the draft come to us. Even if we took a QB, it's been better to let them sit and learn the 1st year or part of it than shove them straight into the fire unless there's no other choice. Too much risk for a QB that wasn't likely to be an elite franchise QB anyway based on the history of overall 1st pick QBs. If that Manning or Luck caliber QB had been available, Chicago wouldn't have traded out.
-
Championship Round Playoff Thread
SmokinwithWilly replied to kungfoodude's topic in Carolina Panthers
And brought to you by a pharmaceutical company. I wonder why. -
Championship Round Playoff Thread
SmokinwithWilly replied to kungfoodude's topic in Carolina Panthers
Maybe not, but he can run the system and doesn't look like he's got one foot in the NFL grave and one on a banana peel. You have to have someone capable. Dalton most definitely has not been the past 2 years, arguably 3. -
Championship Round Playoff Thread
SmokinwithWilly replied to kungfoodude's topic in Carolina Panthers
Interesting that they just brought up the point of having a real backup QB because your season can be over from one bad break if you don't. Hope Dan is listening. -
Sam Darnold can’t throw the ball past the line of scrimmage.
SmokinwithWilly replied to hepcat's topic in Carolina Panthers
He had one game in the playoffs, and that last drive was anything but clutch. However, if it wasn't for the epic collapse of the Bucs, the Saints not starting Shough earlier in the season, or the Falcons bailing us out with a win we couldn't get ourselves, there is no playoff game. Yay, we made the playoffs at 8-9. That ain't happening every year. You gotta be clutch during the season too and we didn't see that. To be clutch in the playoffs you have to get there. Bryce's performance this year is taking no one there except in the NFCS on a really bad year. Criticize Darnold all you want, but he wasn't the one sitting on the couch cheering on another team to get him there, because he failed badly to get us there when he needed to be "clutch." You may not consider him clutch in the playoffs, but he's gotten 2 teams there, both with very good records too. It's an unpopular opinion, but I think if you can't win your division with a winning record you shouldn't be in the playoffs unless by some miracle your wildcard record gets you in. It's just another participation trophy if you do. -
REPORT: Cade Mays will hit the free-agent market
SmokinwithWilly replied to TheSpecialJuan's topic in Carolina Panthers
This has been the attitude that's given us horrible centers since Kalil injured his neck. This is not a good center class to draft one high, but having the attitude that anyone will do calling all the protections for the line has proven to be the wrong approach for years.
