Wundrbread33

But Corral didn’t play well in 3 quarters of 4th string rookie preseason hE’s A bUsT fire him into the sun. And he’s tOo LiTtLe we should draft Bryce Young ddddduuuuuuuhhhhhh.

Why is everyone acting like OP is delusional? They simply asked a question based on a hypothetical (that wasn’t even that crazy of a hypothetical). Slow down and read. If you’re bothered, don’t participate in the thread.

I know our defense got lucky on one play, but these ratings say they got lucky the whole day?

Well what about everything else that CMC is elite at? Those things don’t contribute to winning? Positive yardage doesn’t contribute to winning? Nearly always making the first defender whiff doesn’t contribute to winning? Having elite WR hands doesn’t contribute to winning? You’re running up the middle example. When was this? Early in his career? He is fine running up the middle now, even if it’s not his ideal usage. Would you likewise penalize Nick Chubb if his coach decided he should split out wide and wasn’t productive doing so? I always find it odd when individual players are held accountable for the whole team winning or losing. We haven’t had a respectable QB/HC since Cam. That’s CMC’s fault? It’s not so simple as “look at our record with CMC. He isn’t a winner.” It’s just more complicated than that, especially in the ultimate of team sports.

Any given Sunday always applies. So many variables and parody. That’s what makes this sport so damn interesting.

So the 49ers losing to KC was partially CMC’s fault? GTFOH

Lockers stock dropped substantially. I’m a Mizzou fan, and consistently watching Gabbert made it obvious he wasn’t the dude. Cam was easily the best. He had/has a narrative around him about his character (which would hang with him his whole career, even after proving otherwise). Cam showed up at the combine and was a man amongst boys. Clear number one regarding talent, frame, and results. I remember seeing that SI cover and laughing. Even the way they are positioned in the photo makes it obvious.

Even after drafting Corral, I still wanted us to take Howell because why not? Lol Those two were my favorite QB’s in the draft.

It goes to show that with this defense, establishing the run, and having average or “game manager” quality QB play, this team is competitive. (Not different to what a lot of us thought prior to the season, and hoped we could get from Baker) Let’s see if Walker can do similar each week. If he could do so, he could “Rodney Peete” for Corral or another QB in this draft.

Tanking just isn’t needed in the NFL.

I mean even Peppers was “lazy, took plays off, and loved basketball more than football.” Cam, from a talent standpoint, was undeniable. “Can he make reads” was the question on the field. And the rest was “he’s a selfish thug stealing laptops.” So I get the point, but he had number 1 potential and ability. A lot of criticism was just talk, and even outright hit pieces. I don’t see that QB in this draft, where the top 2 have huge concerns regarding exceptional supporting talent, and physical limitation.

Remember “Tank for Howell”? Happens every year to a degree.

So people who disagree just aren’t knowledgeable. Sweet. The Browns got their guy a few years back. Now he’s on our team, while two MVP caliber QB’s went after him. It’s just not that simple, and tanking in the NFL isn’t the same as the NBA, where #1 truly matters.

Why do you think he’s a rich man’s Corral? Corral never had this level of talent around him, nor the line. I like how Young scans the field, but I can’t ignore how many times he gets 5+ seconds to do so. The talent surrounding him is just as big of a red flag as his size IMO.

When QB’s get hit, it’s typically 250+ pound men who do the hitting. Not the same as Desean Jackson getting tackled by corners.

Sure, but it’s not irrelevant that in this example, the Colts used the 4th overall pick to draft another back to replace him. Another hall of famer.

Chinn will be the fuging man once he’s back playing as an in box safety.

Charlotte Hornets. It was a joke because they always suck too.

Fair point. Would do you prefer between those two?

I think it’s far more likely Anderson is Peppers vs. these QB’s are Cam.

I was around. It was so easy to fall in love with the potential. Red flags? Absolutely. But the dude was one of, if not the most physically gifted QB prospect of all time, and he dominated the SEC, carrying Auburn on his back. The main concern was “CaM iS a SeLfIsH tHuG” which always needs to be taken with a grain of salt.

Well philosophically any discussion about the panthers, ever, isn’t worth having because we can’t impact anything as fans. So discussing the draft is pointless, unless we are in position to discuss with Fitterer/new coach. Discussing potential coaches is a waste unless we are discussing with Fitt/Tepper. Seems silly cherry picking what is worth talking about, if, in the end, all of the discussion is pointless anyway because we don’t have say.

If he was used the right way, he isn’t pigeonholed as simply a ”running back”. He’d have a Deebo type value instead. To be fair, considering his injury history, I think San Fran have us “shifty Deebo with injury history” value.

Sure. The trade is done. Can’t have discussion though? Chinn doesn’t appear as valuable 30 yards away from the ball, but his value is obvious when used correctly. Thats all I’m saying. CMC was used wrong. Which impacts/limits his ability to help win games. But sure. He’s gone. Doesn’t matter. You are right about that.