Sup

I think some people are missing a simple point. If you put a ton of resources into a guy, you're going to give him every chance to succeed. That's reasonable, not stupid. But that benefit of the doubt has its limits, and three years is pretty much the limit. Unless he consistently plays very well the last four weeks he either will be gone or at least will have a fight on his hands. You can't just look at the past and assume it will continue into the future.

Very good. But he's been bad most of this year. You think they're going to make a huge decision that involves nine figures because two games? The team and FO know most of the wins have been in spite of him, not because of him. I don't know why you won't just admit you think he's the guy, it's not an insane position, it's just not popular on this board. You keep saying what you think the team thinks, what do you think? Where would you rank him among NFL QBs? Would you extend his contact?

He didn't just suck as a rookie. He sucked TWO WEEKS AGO

You literally did compare him to Mayfield. One is a top 10 QB, one is a bottom 10 QB. NFL teams replace crappy QBs all the time.

That's a legitimate question. I think two things here. One, I think there is a recognition it was a mistake to roll with Dalton as the only other QB. At a total minimum I am certain Dalton will be cut and a real backup brought in. Could be a vet Mariota or Winston or could be younger upside guy like Howell or Lance. But I'd bet anything that will happen. Two, the better we are the more obvious it is that we could be legit if we had a good QB. When we sucked it was easy to give Bryce a pass and let him grow as a passer. Times have changed. We could make a playoff run with just decent QB play. We will either sign Jones or throw darts to see what we get. Last, Tepper may like Bryce and want to protect his ego for drafting him, but you don't make a billion without being cold blooded when necessary. Canales and Morgan aren't dumb. They will tell Tepper at a minimum we need real competition, and he will pitch Bryce to the side if he thinks it means a shot at getting to the SB. Too many people here (not you) think that because Bryce has been protected that will go on forever. It won't.

I think you're going to be surprised by what happens this offseason then. yeah, maybe they pick up the 5th year option. But there is no way they're going to roll into 26 with only Bryce as a legitimate QB. And if he loses the job in camp or preseason, he loses it. The comparison to Mayfield is a huge stretch. Mayfield is a good QB, Bryce is not.

They are not going to poo on him in pressers during the season, but they are not stupid and they see just how much he is holding this team back.

But the thing is, Bryce is so mediocre/bad that anyone they bring in will be competition.

Why do you think Bryce would beat out whoever we bring in? If you ranked the NFL QBs, where would you put him?

The crazy thing is, I agree that there is a perception that he's on a hot streak, but he actually isn't. He's had two good games out of the last six, with the rest being various levels of mid-to-poo. It's just that our expectations have gotten so beat down over the last 3 years, him looking competent feels like he's playing awesome. Dude is graded on the ultimate curve.

Top two needs are off ball LB and QB competition/backup.

He starts not just games but whole seasons ice cold. Then he finishes lukewarm. Sometimes.

Yes, I thought great QBs you want to keep around usually pass for around 140 a game and like to fumble. I've never heard of production like this

Yes because most of the wins have been in spite of him. I will acknowledge he has had some very good games but you can't succeed with a guy that inconsistent. And the idea of regretting letting him go because he turns into Mayfield or Darnold is ridiculous. Bryce has had like five good games here. Who gaf if he has five good games over the next three years?

I agree, I just think Bryce will lose.